0:16:05 Thursday 23 October 2025

Income Insurance Scheme: A bone of contention

The Government's proposal would help the newly unemployed, but some are opposed to the proposal. Photos: Angus Dreaver/RNZ.

The National Party has launched a campaign to stop Labour's proposed Income Insurance Scheme.

The scheme was first put forward in the 2021 Budget, is modelled on similar social insurance schemes in Europe and would provide a new ACC-like safety net for workers who found themselves unemployed.

On Tuesday, September 20, the Government released hundreds of submissions from employers, business groups, unions and individuals, who responded to a discussion on the document issued in February.

Some of the country's largest employers but also the Salvation Army and Child Poverty Action Group came out against the scheme, though for largely different reasons.

Officials estimated last year that the scheme would cost $3.5 billion a year, depending on how many were made unemployed.

The scheme would be funded by a tax on workers and employers, who would both be expected to pay approximately 1.39 per cent of employees' pay - a 2.77 per cent tax in total.

National Finance spokesperson Nicola Willis. Photo: RNZ.

Finance spokesperson for the National Party Nicola Willis says the new "jobs tax" will make Kiwis across the country $834 'worse off every year,” and many people are not aware about the Government plan.

She likens the plan to the now scrapped "Kiwisaver tax" proposal to standardise the application of GST to fees and services of managed fund providers.

'Despite major financial challenges facing New Zealanders, Finance Minister Grant Robertson expects you to give away more of your already-stretched pay packets to pay for his pet project,” says Willis.

'Many people will be surprised to learn of Labour's quiet plan to impose a new 1.39 per cent Jobs Tax on every working Kiwi and every employer.

'National will be campaigning to make sure New Zealanders know about it before it's too late to stop it.

'The new Jobs Tax would make a typical worker (earning $60,000) $834 worse off every year. That's $834 less for groceries, bills, and people's own savings. It's a cost Kiwis can't afford.

'This latest tax grab by Labour is being proposed to pay for an ‘income insurance' scheme. This gold-plated welfare scheme would allow people made redundant from their jobs to stay out of work for up to six months on 80 per cent pay. It would come with a multi-billion price tag.

'Employers will also be hit with a new 1.39 per cent tax, meaning they'll have less cash available for pay rises and may be forced to hike prices to pay for it.”

Finance Minister Grant Robertson. Photo: RNZ.

Finance Minister Grant Robertson says Willis' statement is 'misleading,” and the Governments 'financial decisions on the scheme's design have yet been made”.

'While everyone's situation will be different under the income insurance scheme, reflecting their circumstances. As an example, for a person earning $1160 a week, they would pay $16.12 a week in levies,” says Finance Minister Grant Roberson.

'If they lost their job and were eligible for support, they would then receive $928 per week in insurance payments.

'This scheme is needed and came about as a result of the urging of Business New Zealand and the Council of Trade Unions. New Zealand is among only a few countries in the OECD without an income insurance scheme, which will fill a gap in our social security system.

'Currently, when redundancy or health conditions and disability results in someone losing their job, New Zealanders get far less support than those in practically any other advanced country.

'Some 100,000 New Zealanders lose their job every year and during a major economic shock like the Global Financial Crisis, 200,000 found themselves out of work. The Government has worked alongside Business New Zealand and the CTU to develop a scheme to provide an enduring solution to protect workers and the economy after job losses.

'It is also important to note that final decisions on the scheme's design have yet been made. In any event it is not due to come into place until 2024 at the earliest.”

Willis adds the plan by the Government is 'yet another case of skewed priorities from a Government that is increasingly out of touch with New Zealand families”.

'National is determined to speak up for hardworking New Zealanders who are already being hit by rising prices and higher interest rates and who can't afford to pay yet another new tax.”

'We are campaigning to stop this tax and have pledged that if Labour do introduce it, National will repeal it.

'People power stopped Labour's KiwiSaver Tax, now it's time to stop the Jobs Tax too.”

- Additional reporting by Tom Pullar-Strecker/Stuff.co.nz.

5 comments

More NEW taxes

Posted on 29-09-2022 09:13 | By an_alias

Yep while business struggle Labours solution is to add yet another tax on business. What rational govt would think in a recession this would help ?


Hmmm

Posted on 29-09-2022 11:40 | By Let's get real

So what happens to those close to retirement with stable employment and no opt-out opportunity...? The government are currently falling over themselves to issue documents which will allow employers to bring qualified employees into the country on one hand and are looking to introduce another tax to support redundant employees....? Surely it's going to be used to pay useless ex-employees to have a few weeks off before getting another job or signing on for another government handout.


@ an_alias

Posted on 29-09-2022 11:43 | By Yadick

Couldn't add any more to your comment. You sum it up perfectly. Remember too, the petrol subsidy comes off soon too.


Yep another levy not a tax yeah right

Posted on 29-09-2022 12:30 | By Kancho

So yep load up tax, break the promise again even calling it a levy haha as if that makes a difference. Talking OECD then we are the bottom of productivity stats of other countries. Productivity equals earnings to pay for these nice to haves. Labour should of course be looking after the lower income people with taking GST off food which is easy to accomplish in the digital age. Adding taxes to workers and employers is obviously inflationary too. So stupid to fuel inflation more. Inflation tends to drop off but not reverse.


TAX

Posted on 30-09-2022 08:33 | By Slim Shady

Good to see Labour moving into the game of expensive needless insurance schemes. Only with this one it’s not the suckers who take it out who pay for it. It’s all the other suckers who cannot avoid it. Therefore, it’s a tax. Labour - the party of high taxes, high borrowing and high inflation.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.