“Nurses frustrated” as pay agreement stalls

Nurses strike outside Christchurch Hospital in June 2021 Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon.

A union says nurses are deeply frustrated as a four-year fight for a gender pay equity agreement stalls again.

Nurses Organisation members had been set to vote on an agreement with the District Health Boards last month, but some were unhappy it did not include the amount of backpay they were expecting.

Now, the 40,000 members have voted to take it to the Employment Relations Authority instead.

Nurses Organisation chief executive Paul Goulter says it will also ask the authority to rule on two more problems that have emerged after talking to members - whether senior nurses are getting enough of an increase and how often gender pay will be reviewed.

Nurses feel the authority is the best place to settle the dispute and they want it done quickly, he says.

"The nurses are deeply frustrated - and I'm sure on the employers side that is the case as well."

Spokesperson for the DHBs, Tairāwhiti DHB chief executive Jim Green, says it doesn't understand what has gone wrong, because the union had agreed to wording in settlement in December.

That included lump sump payments to recognise the time taken to reach an agreement, and a process to make sure the gender pay gains are not eroded over time.

There would have to be mediation before any employment relations hearing, he says.

Nurses first started their fight for pay equity in 2018 - to address years of underpayment because they are a workforce made up predominantly of women.

A settlement appeared to have been reached late last year but problems emerged last month, when some nurses noticed they were not getting backpaid to December 2019 as they had expected.

Health Minister Andrew Little has said if the union was successful, it could add hundreds of millions of dollars to the cost of the pay equity claim.

Goulter says only about 40 per cent of nurses in New Zealand worked for DHBs and many more are waiting on the outcome of the dispute before making their own claims.

The agreement was never set in stone as the DHBs are implying, it's always a draft until the nurses voted on it, he says.

-RNZ/Rowan Quinn.

4 comments

Not only nurses

Posted on 10-05-2022 18:17 | By Get our roads

As far as I'm concerned the gender pay gap exists in every occupation in the world, God only knows why, especially in the corporate world, women have been undervalued and ripped off for centuries, Business owners need to realise that women have a lot more to offer them then men, we are great at multitasking, do not have a chip on our shoulders like a lot of old executives and we work faster. The days of keeping women are long gone, we are independent, reliable and go through so much more in life than a man. Stop ripping women off and pay them what they deserve, it should be written in law that no business owner is allowed to pay a male more than a female in any occupation and they should have to publicly display what they pay their women and men for all roles.


Gender pay equity.

Posted on 11-05-2022 12:56 | By morepork

Surely this is a phrase taken from Queen Victoria's time? Why would it still be an issue in the 21st century? If the person working alongside of you is doing the same job, in what Universe would it be OK NOT to pay both of you the same wage? Maybe if you are working next to a trained chimpanzee, there could be an argument for paying them less (chimps work for peanuts anyway...) Do we consider women then, to be trained chimpanzees? This phrase should not be heard in this century. It should have been settled long ago.


@Get Our Roads

Posted on 11-05-2022 13:03 | By morepork

Throughout my career, I worked in an industry (Information Technology) where women were ALWAYS paid the same as men. There was a rate for Programmers, and it didn't matter if you were a trained chimpanzee (as I mentioned elsewhere), that was what you were paid. You wrote the code and took the money. It was a surprise to me in later life to find that in many industries, women were paid less. There is no possible justification for it and we shouldn't even be discussing it. I agree with your sentiments, but I don't agree it is true in "EVERY occupation".


It is just sad...

Posted on 12-05-2022 11:21 | By morepork

...to see medical workers still having to fight for a decent wage. It has been commented on many times here and we all know it is shameful, but a profligate Government that can print and waste billions of dollars on a political agenda that benefits a select few, cannot seem to find funds for workers who benefit all of us. If Health is understaffed, if our young, qualified people leave to work overseas, whose fault is it but our own?


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.