Tauranga bins: maggots and mounting bottles

The little green food scraps bins is currently not being collected in Tauranga.

Bins are once again causing a stink in Tauranga, with residents complaining about a build-up of maggot-infested rubbish and ever-growing collections of wine and beer bottles.

Some of the city's ratepayers are now demanding refunds from Tauranga City Council, who stand accused of operating a 'monopoly” with 'draconian rules”.

Tauranga City Council and Western Bay of Plenty District Council reduced rubbish services earlier this month, citing Covid-related staff shortages as the main reason. Neither glass crates nor food scrap bins are being collected until further notice.

Te Puke resident Shelley Connon says her food scraps have not been collected for three weeks. Despite regular cleaning and hosing, she says bins have quickly become infested with maggots, cockroaches and ants.

'I keep meat waste in the freezer until the last minute,” says Connon, 'but with them not collecting it for so long – and it's either been stinking hot or raining – it's not surprising that the bins are attracting insects and vermin.”

Connon, who rents the house from her father who is a ratepayer, objects to having to pay for a service that is not being delivered.

'Why should I pay for expensive fuel and fees to take stuff to the dump when it's supposed to be covered in the rates that my father pays?”

Connon also says her red recycling bin is not big enough for food and glass, and claims the community is becoming increasingly exasperated. 'If you ask for a bigger bin you are charged more,” she says.

'It's one of so many tough things people are dealing with in life at the moment with Covid, but this should be easily fixed and ratepayers should be given a refund.”

Maungatapu resident Philip Ewens agrees.

'They should offer ratepayers a refund for the lack of service,” he says. 'They can say it's Omicron that's buggered up their plans, but then why are we still paying for it?”

Ewens is 'disgusted” to see rubbish, including plastic bags and cardboard, blowing down the street while he was walking his dog this week.

'There was so much that it was blocking the drains,” he says.

Ewens complained via Tauranga City Council's contact centre and says the rubbish was cleaned up on Wednesday morning.

'The whole system is a rip off,” says Ewens. 'The extra bin for food scraps - even when they are collecting it - is a pain in the backside.

'There's often spilled rubbish. I've seen broken glass on the ground, which is a hazard. Then there's ...those who come around and look in your bin to check compliance with their system, tape up the bin and leave you a note. It's Draconian.”

Golden Sands resident Hayden Goldsack is composting food scraps, but says it's 'laziness” from council not to adapt to the challenges of staff shortages like other businesses have. Hayden runs a lawn mowing business with 70 staff.

'You can implement measures like everyone else has, like extra sanitising and safety and juggling staff rosters, and still continue a good service,” he says.

Goldsack says he has been taking his own glass to the recycling station.

'We have been homeschooling the kids, so our empty bottles have been mounting up.”

Pāpāmoa resident Stanley Burlison understands that councils are battling staff shortages, and that complaints about rubbish collection might seem like a 'first-world problem”, but his point is about the charges.

”I can drive the glass to the dump, and will do so if the council gives me a rebate for me doing something I am paying them to do,” says Burlison.

'The council should be managed like any other business. If you cannot provide a service, customers need to be charged accordingly.

'Council made a conscious decision to put almost all other waste collection companies out of business so that it could manage this service themselves. Now they have the monopoly, they need to deliver.”

Tauranga City Council sustainability and waste manager Sam Fellows says there are no plans in place to refund ratepayers.

'We still pay our drivers while they are off sick or isolating,” says Fellows. 'Kerbside collections are a targeted rate that encompasses the full service provided, including the rubbish and recycling bins.

'There is no set rate for only glass and food scraps, and it is not charged weekly.”

He acknowledged not everyone is happy, but others in the community have been supportive, he says.

'We have received some negative comments on social media regarding the reduced level of service, while others in the community have voiced their support for the wellbeing of our contractors during this challenging time.”

Fellows points out that, in the meantime, people can put their food scraps in their red bin which is still collected fortnightly.

He recommends people to store glass then 'drip feed it into the glass collections once full service resumes, take it to the transfer station or, as a last resort, put it in the red waste bin.”

Western Bay of Plenty District Council deputy CEO and group manager infrastructure services, Gary Allis.

Western Bay of Plenty District Council deputy CEO and group manager infrastructure services, Gary Allis, says there is no plan to refund Western Bay ratepayers either.

'We appreciate the reduction in service is an inconvenience, but there are no plans to reimburse for loss of service,” says Allis.

'The cost to the ratepayer in doing so would by far outweigh the benefit of any refund. When glass collections resume, excess can be fed back into the glass crates, providing crates are not overfull.

'This inconvenience to our service will hopefully be short term and will have no real impact on the overall costs associated with our eight-year contract.”

He says Western Bay of Plenty District Council has not received any reports of rubbish piling up since the reduced kerbside collection service was implemented, but recycling centre staff have seen an increase in people bringing in glass and other recyclables.

Tauranga City Council began a rates-funded kerbside collection service in July 2021, which aims to halve the amount of household waste that Tauranga residents send to landfill by 2028.

The new service included a weekly food scraps collection, which aims to reduce the amount of food that ends up in landfill when it could be composted.

Currently, 33 per cent of Tauranga's household waste sent to landfill is food scraps, says Fellows.

'When food ends up in landfill, it rots without oxygen and releases methane – a gas that's harmful to our environment and contributes to climate change.

'By using the food scraps bin for your leftover food, fruit and vegetables, meat, fish and bones, egg and seafood shells, we can reduce the amount of food we send to landfill and in turn reduce the cost to our environment.”

However, from March 7, council has not collected food scraps or glass, citing 'driver shortages due to the impacts of the Omicron outbreak in our community”.

-Stuff/Annemarie Quill.

17 comments

User pays

Posted on 25-03-2022 09:30 | By The Sage

This is yet another example of something being thrust on the rate payers, like the Commissioners, with no choice and enforced payment. At the very least ratepayers should have had the option of using other providers. I stuck with Kleana Bins, no problems with them. I have to pay the Council for a service I do not use because of my decision. My choice I know however there is something very wrong with that picture.


Expected Outcome

Posted on 25-03-2022 10:01 | By Local Too

There is no good reason why these bins aren't picked up. You now have one operator and at their whim they decide. Its a complete mess.


Refund

Posted on 25-03-2022 10:21 | By The Professor

I hear what the WB CEO is saying about the cost of refunding being expensive, but what Council can do is to delay the charges next year or make an adjustment to the fee for next year, so ratepayers only pay for 10 months service but get 12 months. I might test this at a tribunal if Vouncil don't agree.


So much rubbish . . .

Posted on 25-03-2022 10:27 | By bigted

Council must have a 'non-performance' clause in the contract with the rubbish collector company. Short, or long term, we ratepayers are paying for a service we are now not getting. Great system eh!


Think outside the box TCC

Posted on 25-03-2022 10:31 | By nerak

In today's news: 'An anaesthetist at Nelson Hospital has been pulled in to work in the emergency department as Nelson Marlborough Health juggles staff shortages while dealing with Covid-19.' Of course, we ratepayers cannot possibly expect TCC staff to pick up food scrap bins and empty them into the truck, can we? Surely that would be beneath their higher calling. Ratepayers should not be paying for non service. Refunds are common place in well run businesses, but then, TCC is neither a business nor well run, just a comfortable job for all staff, with a more than comfortable reimbursement while most of them dream up things the ratepayers neither want nor need.


What a joke...

Posted on 25-03-2022 10:45 | By fair game

Those with COVID only need to be off work for 7 days. Why no collections for 6 weeks?? Get more drivers, employ drivers on short term contracts and sort your mess out. So unfair that we are propping up this Chinese company with no service provided for doing so.


Why

Posted on 25-03-2022 11:17 | By Yadick

Can they not employ someone else to fill in like every other business haves to, to keep their services going. You don't just take payment and not give the services offered. That's theft, we see it on Fair Go all the time. I believe Fair Go refers to them as rogues and fraudsters.


It's absolute BS!

Posted on 25-03-2022 11:56 | By Bruja

Hospitality, for example, small businesses have been 'coping' with staffing issues. loss of income for 2 years!!! YOU FORCED the system on us, YOU killed off local businesses to feed a Chinese company, YOU sort it and quickly! It's yet ANOTHER TCC disgrace!


Monopoly never works

Posted on 25-03-2022 12:22 | By an_alias

You need competition so that failures go out of business. Council should have only had a service that competed against private business to prove they are better. We now have the usual useless public sector that can do what it wants and no one can go elsewhere


The fact is...

Posted on 25-03-2022 12:27 | By morepork

...That the Council (pressed by 10B) opted to impose a single rubbish system and they decided they could handle it and manage it properly. There was fierce objection (especially from those of us who were more than happy with our existing service providers, most of whom were Kiwi companies...), but the deal went to China. Now, they are finding that when things go wrong (like staff shortages due to Covid) they CAN'T handle it properly. ANY other business, when it fails to deliver a contracted service, credits the client or refunds their money. This Service not only fails to do that but thinks that the public are "mean" to suggest it. They are so used to spending other people's money without responsibility that they get miffed when people suggest that they follow standard business practice. Fix the service or credit the Rates; it's simple really.


Glass ripoff

Posted on 25-03-2022 12:55 | By tia

Council staff are on another planet. 1. You don't employ the staff Mr. Fallows. You engage a contractor to perform. 2. both Councils would have difficulty defending a charge under the Consumers Guarantee's Act for having a 'contract' with a client(ratepayer) and now not meeting their 'contract'. 3. See what happens if ratepayers are late of don't pay their rates. 4. I will bet that these council professionals will be looking to a pay increase when their annual performance assessment is carried out later this year - and who will be paying - you guessed it - the Ratepayer.


Kept our private service

Posted on 25-03-2022 13:20 | By jed

The council rubbish collection service is not as they originally advertised. We find it totally useless, so keep our private provider.... the council provide a worse service for more money.


Fairs fair

Posted on 25-03-2022 13:41 | By Mommatum

At first I went along with no food/glass collections. However now the Prime Minister is signalling an end to. Ovid restriction, plus restrictions are just for seven days so fairs fair. Also I believe your drivers are still getting paid? Why when no work is being done and who said refunds wouldn’t be in order. People are having to make other arrangements for rubbish, council wanted this service to be one size fits all and now at the first hurdle they can’t cope. Doesn’t look good at all by my reckoning,


Clawback

Posted on 25-03-2022 16:38 | By Slim Shady

The contractors were squeezed by the Council taking it over. Now the contractors are squeezing back by using Covid as an excuse. Council don’t care because they just collect our money regardless. They need to resume what we pay for or it’s grounds for withholding payment. And I suspect an increase in illegal dumping.


Maybe...

Posted on 25-03-2022 16:46 | By fair game

we just all take our glass to the City Council - it's closer for me than the dump, so that saves me money for a start. I bet the Council will then have to employ someone to pick it up.... food for thought!


Errrrrrrrr What?

Posted on 25-03-2022 19:05 | By Bob Landy

I don’t want to side with the council but, food scraps go in general rubbish, washed glass will not get infested, rubbish blowing down the street is the fault of whoever put it out. Personally I’m very happy not using the green bin, have no problem with glass and nothing I put out blows down the street.


Absolute Trash

Posted on 26-03-2022 08:23 | By Thats Nice

Spot on tia and Bruja . Staff shortages are because they're getting paid tiddly winks so leave for better $$ not Covid. I have never used the 2 smaller bins and never will.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.