The claim by Mike von Lande (June 29) that Treaty settlement payments already total many $billions is completely contradicted by official figures from the Office of Treaty Settlements (OTS).
Mike says that the fisheries settlement transferred over a $billion to Maori. OTS says $170 million.
He says that some tribes have received settlements of half a $billion in forestry assets. OTS says the forestry settlement was $160 million for all tribes to share.
He says that there are scores more payments like Ngai Tahu and Tainui for hundreds of $millions each. OTS says that Ngai Tahu got $170 million, Tainui got $170 million, and only one other tribe has got over $50 million.
Official figures from OTS are available at the Wikipedia site 'treaty of Waitangi claims and settlements”. The total for claims from 1992 to 2008 is $950 million. Completed settlements since then are about $200 million making a total to date of just over $1 billion.
Since 1992 total Government spending has been over $1000 billion (Treasury), so $1 billion of Treaty settlements is 0.1% of Government spending.
Treaty settlements are not gifts. They are a justified compensation for Government injustice. They are not an excessive cost to the taxpayer.
Peter Dey, Welcome Bay.


4 comments
Marxism in excess ?
Posted on 09-07-2012 20:01 | By Scambuster
Mike van Lande is a lot closer to the mark than you will ever be mate.Your problem is if you feed rubbish into your head you get rubbish out.Payments are not gifts they are not justified compensation they are rorts perpetrated on other NZers.
fair payment not a rort
Posted on 11-07-2012 19:08 | By Peter Dey
Maori had land taken by the Government without payment. Now the land is being paid for. That is not a rort.
They are Rorts allright ParoaPete.
Posted on 12-07-2012 20:10 | By Scambuster
Read Mike Butler in Breaking Views .co.nz (1 July 2012) on Ngati Ranginui Settlement @$38m + and I think even the tunnel visionists might just get the full picture.If it looks like a rort it sounds like a rort it tests as a rort and it smells like a rort then it is a RORT !!
IT IS A FAKE SETTLEMENT
Posted on 12-07-2012 22:07 | By YOGI
The treaty has nothing to do with land, trees, forests, beaches or water ... the Maori wanted the Poms to save them that is all there is to it.
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.