A 72-year-old Tauranga woman, whose family is the victim of four Blue Chip property investment scams, is asking for the public's help as family members die and her unpayable debt grows.
In 2001 Margaret Rasmussen made a deposit with the Auckland Residential Property Trust of $192,000.
It was for an apartment in Auckland and followed dealings with trustee Mark Bryers – the founder of failed finance group Blue Chip.
Margaret Rasmussen is having a weary retirement, stressed by the spectre of unpayable mortgages on non-existent properties.
The apartment did not exist and her mortgage for it is now worth more than $300,000.
'They took our money, gave us nothing in return, promised us an apartment; they even took our money for chattels for the non-existent apartment on land they didn't even own – and said it was covered by insurance, which it wasn't, and now they want to take my house,” says Margaret.
When she confronted the trust, part of the Blue Chip group, she says she was told the apartment would be built in 90 days or she would get her money back.
She then approached the Auckland City Council.
'When we went to the Auckland City Council they said they never even put in for a building permit.”
Her efforts to reacquire the money have come to naught and she is claiming foul play in the dealings with Blue Chip.
'They have stolen my money and when we went to the Serious Fraud Squad they said they couldn't find any fraud.”
Margaret claims to have evidence to the contrary.
'I've got papers where they have taken my signature off one and put it onto another and they tell me that's legal because they call it an electronic signature.
'Mum was put down as a professional investor at 88, and I was put down as an investor, but I wasn't professional, and they just put whatever they liked down – I didn't even get to see any of the papers.”
Margaret bears the burden of two Blue Chip properties, her own and her mother's, which has a mortgage of over $400,000 owing.
Her brother and daughter-in-law's mother are also bearers of Blue Chip debt.
These mortgages are held with Advantedge, which has given Margaret until March to pay-up on, or it will seize her other property.
The emotional strain of this financial burden is taking its toll on Margaret and her family with her husband dying in 2011, and then just two weeks later her brother dying also.
Her mother and uncle both died soon after.
'They (Advantedge) are going to start putting in process proceedings and my doctor wrote a letter saying ‘I'm not in a fit state because I've had four of my family die this year (2011)'.”
The doctor's letter to Advantedge expressed how Margaret is ‘not fit to make decisions', but this effort appears forlorn.
'They've said they're not listening to him – so they want to go ahead anyway.”
Margaret is seeking the public's support in her plight and is asking people to begin a letter writing campaign.
'Everybody needs to write to the government or to Winston Peters, or somebody who is going to do something; or Simon Bridges, Brendan Horan, any of them.
'I would like them to have a lot of letters to try and make them do something because we have been fighting for three years.”
Margaret says earlier attempts to secure help from Prime Minister John Key, then Justice Minister Simon Power, and Tauranga MP Simon Bridges all failed.
'They all just say they can't do anything.”
But she is optimistic with enough letters they will be forced to help.
There are about 800 people affected by Blue Chip scams and Margaret says they are all in regular contact.
Bryers escaped a prison sentence in 2010 when he pleaded guilty to 34 charges related to mismanagement and improper accounting at Blue Chip.
He was sentenced to 75 hours of community work and to pay a fine of $33,750.
When Blue Chip collapsed in 2008 it owed about 3000 investors more than $80 million.
18 comments
Monay scams never stop
Posted on 06-01-2012 13:09 | By CC8
.
Money scams never stop!
Posted on 06-01-2012 13:20 | By CC8
So a crooked scam artist can make false mortgages and sell property that never existed, then legitimise the debt by selling on the finance/mortgage to some other entity...in this case Advantedge ( which by the way is part of NAB , which operates in New Zealand as BNZ.) Just because Advantedge has bought the debt does not make it right or cover the fraud..... They bought a lemon, they should be made to suck it.
ADVANTEDGE FINANCIAL
Posted on 06-01-2012 13:46 | By Openknee8ted
Is this the company? Backed by NAB of National Bank Fame and Post Bank in NZ. If so you may want to consider changing bank and tell your bank manager why.
THIS STINKS!
Posted on 06-01-2012 14:00 | By bryceh
I am not aware of the full story about these investments, but will now read more about it. However with this size of a problem, I smell a rat! Why is nobody doing anything about this, if as this lady says, there are 800 people who have been ripped off?? REMEMBER the politicians work for the PEOPLE! DEMAND ACTION if you think action is justified on LEGAL grounds!!! If it is all emotional and argumentative then maybe things are not going to be so easy! With all investments, there is a need for due diligence, and maybe this was not completely investigated in the beginning.
Let the buyer beware !
Posted on 06-01-2012 14:54 | By Zara
There are always plenty of sheep waiting to be shorn. Maybe she should have done what I did and burst out laughing when she was contacted by the Blue Chip bunnies. I asked if it was such a good deal why did they need me to sell it to first, why not just sell it to the end user.They could not explain. Many lawyers around the country tried in vain to dissuade their clients but they went ahead anyway only to come back months later and ask the same lawyer what could be done to resolve the problem and were all given the same answer,too late, you should have listened to the old adage, IF IT SOUNDS TOO GOOD TO BE TRUE IT PROBABLY ISN'T .Do not ask for my money to cover your stupidity.
LOOK OF 'SUB-PRIME' ABOUT IT!
Posted on 06-01-2012 15:58 | By WOFTAM
Looks to me that the original bank has 'sold' the debt for a token amount and the new owner now wants to collect. That means that the original bank has been repaid in full so nothing is owing so nothing to collect from you.
Disgusting
Posted on 06-01-2012 16:25 | By Jitter
The company Advantedge are just as bad and crooked as Blue Chip when they are demanding repayment of mortgages on non existent properties. Mark Bryers and his fellow trustees are the people who should have their property seized not these innocent investors who were taken in by a sophisticated scam. It is obvious that this whole development was planned this way by Bryers and co so these are the crooks who should be made to pay. If Advantedge carry out their threat on these investors they should be put out of business and forced to return the seized property. I find their proposed action absolutely disgusting.
email these parasites!!!
Posted on 06-01-2012 16:31 | By cptn scully
Have just looked up Advantedge on the net and they have an email address or 2 one is customercare@advatedge.com.au and the other one is complaints@advantedge.com.au So come on Tauranga get behind this lady and email your disgust direct to them!!!
History
Posted on 06-01-2012 16:35 | By Colleen Spiro
I have just searched the Companies Register and have come up with EIGHT pages of companies that Mark Bryers has been involved with and now has either been struck off or Companies are in liquidation. http://www.facebook.com/l.php?u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.business.govt.nz%2Fcompanies%2Fapp%2Fui%2Fpages%2Findividual%2Fsearch%3Fq%3Dmark%2Bbryers%26start%3D0%26limit%3D25%26entitySearch%26addressKeyword%26postalCode%26country%26addressType%26advancedPanel%26roleType%3DALL%26sf%26sd&h=5AQGBP4-1AQErrQXqrxQwdaAnFPKP20_Q_O-3x3AbR8Nnyg&enc=AZMxm07C5AvDMvDxgn4Bji93i7BVbLN69rrEexgeelrFPk9AgH3YQUFDsfqtCptbg9UvoF7NC3Z0MIJaznMH7t-cy2S_1D0KOCjw13HDvsBQJQ Is it legal for a person who is declared bankrupt or struck off to just carry on doing it.
Govt
Posted on 06-01-2012 17:07 | By Capt_Kaveman
must come in and make this Mark Bryers pay up and i beat his sitting on a million dollar home, key and the like scant help cose prob one of there corp mates
Marks Address:
Posted on 06-01-2012 17:58 | By Colleen Spiro
Mark Ronald BRYERS Residential Address:1404, 98 -100 Gloucester Street, Sydney Nsw 2000, Australia - You might want to tell him what you think of him.
Found this
Posted on 06-01-2012 18:32 | By Colleen Spiro
Neil Owens 10 MAY 2011 12:08A.M. TV3 site There seems to be a common myth that people borrowed to invest in Blue Chip. Blue Chip borrowed money which went into Trust or Blue Chip accounts, or paid huge bonusus to senior staff. Blue Chip promised to service the loan, and pay the client a procurement fee. As the loan Blue Chip raised was against the clients property Blue Chip insured the mortgage in the event of Blue Chip's collapse to protect the clients asset. There was no risk to the client as the insurance would cover it. Well that was the advertising and the product they sold to clients. In reality it was a scam. A double scam. There was either no insurance protection in place, Blue Chip had failed to pay the premium, or because of the fraud the insurance didn't pay out. Blue Chip played a two faced scam. In order to raise the loans they let the lender e.g. GE Money, Westpac, Challenger believe the Blue Chip client was to service the loan. So the loans could be raised they altered the forms after the client had signed them to fit lending criteria and without the clients knowledge. Blue Chip altered income figures, occupation, age, valuations, in some cases forged signatures. Blue Chip were telling clients the mortgage wasn't their responsibility. Blue Chip set up bank accounts in clients names and laundered money through them. My Blue Chip account had large amounts come and go and I was told not to touch it. Blue Chip sold it's product on the reputation of highly skilled people running it. Ex Prime Minister Jim Bolger, ex Deputy Prime Minister Wyatt Creech, and Minister of Commerce John Luxton all in various ways were involved in the running of the Blue Chip scam, and Blue Chip used them in it's sales pitch. I have in my possesion 3 forms. A copy of an original clients form. An email between two Blue Chip associates asking this clients form to be altered. The Altered form. The form was rewritten in another hand with vital information changed, plus the clients signature crudely copied.
What is the full story and reasons 4 the investment ?
Posted on 06-01-2012 19:27 | By KAMIKAZE
Don't wish to be judgmental but for openers the 2001 date doesn't look right and you have to ask why was a 71yo woman and her 81yo mother or whatever age they were at the time ever involved in this idiot magnet scheme. If they had any independent advice it would have been spelt out loud and clear to them what the risks were.It has the look of someone getting greedy and paying the price.Having said that this is no excuse for the rorting that has taken place.Developers lenders etc all played parts that could best be described as immoral and the NZ Government wants a rocket up the artz for allowing this 'wild west' behavior to flourish.The penalties are a bloody joke.Look at your politicians and banks for allowing this to happen.
I feel sorry for family but . . .
Posted on 07-01-2012 09:29 | By Gee Really
I don't think taxpayers should bail people who have made bad investments out. It's usually best to put your money in a bank. The interest is lower but your money is usually safe. The higher the return promised, the more the risk. Part of this trail will lead to "Financial Advisors" or possibly lawyers who recommended Blue Chip. Where are those advisors now?
@CC8
Posted on 07-01-2012 10:42 | By The Tomahawk Kid
That is a very good point and you put it very well. I also agree with Zara. Investment for capital gain is a GAMBLE. If you don't like losing then don't gamble. Its a very dangerous human trait that many succumb to ie trying to increase their wealth without physically doing something productive to achieve it. I do sympathise with this lady but the people who DIDNT lose thousands of their hard-earned savings are those who didn't GAMBLE with them! The money I earn from my productivity is too hard to come by to gamble with it.
SAD STORY BUT ...
Posted on 07-01-2012 15:19 | By DORKLANDER
and no one wishes this upon anyone, but the story is that firstly the law allows these things to happen and go unpunished, Mr. Briers resides happily in Australia for some reason unknown to me. The sales pitch used is a "hard sell" slick advertising and excess commissions and kick backs to advisors, they all become your advocates because they are on the take. There was no 'business model' it was a disaster in the making. I personally have helps dozens through the aftermath of a mess. In this case who on earth would advise someone to mortgage your house and hand over all the money without getting something tangible in exchange and at fair value. The bad advice related to Blue Chip only starts with them, follow the trail of commissions and payouts and see where it takes you. When you see the names on the recipient bank accounts you will be amazed! But we won't get to know about that will we. In ten years time history will repeat and the same stories will be run again because a quick buck, easy money and a slick sales job is what it is all about.
bob dey report on Emily Place
Posted on 08-01-2012 18:32 | By razzy
Published 8 May 2009 Paxton Pacific-related Emily Projects Ltd (Leonard Ross) will start work above ground next week on a 2-tower hotel development on a former Blue Chip site between Anzac Avenue & Emily Place, on the eastern fringe of Auckland's cbd. Earth & foundation works have been under way for the past month. The Celestion development will have 119 non-permanent-stay apartments and NZ Waldorf Apartments Ltd (Avi Rubinstein & Frank Wolf of the Waldorf Apartment Group, Sydney) has been signed up to run the hotel. It will be Waldorf's seventh site in Auckland. The sixth, due for completion at the end of this month, is a Paxton project, Icon Central on St Martin's Lane. It will open as the Waldorf St Martin's Apartment Hotel. 123 of the 155 units have been sold. The Celestion's Anzac Avenue tower will have 16 levels, with 5 units/floor. The 18-level tower fronting Emily Place will have 12 parking spaces & a day spa at the bottom, and 3 units/floor above that. The development is scheduled for completion in June 2010. About 85 of the units have been sold. They're being promoted overseas in a price range of $440-589,000, with a 2-year rental guarantee at 6% net until 2012. A company owned by Marks Bryers' Blue Chip NZ Ltd, Church Crookham Trust Ltd, bought the 1081m² site for $4 million in 2004 and it was transferred in 2006 for $10.9 million to Ile My Ltd - director Mr Bryers, ownership through another of his companies & a trust company. The liquidators of a number of Blue Chip companies (but not these ones), Jeff Meltzer, Arron Heath & Lloyd Hayward, said in their report last August on the whole New Zealand franchise operation of the Blue Chip group, run through Mide Ltd, that this was one of the group's developments that didn't proceed. 'The deposits were not returned to investors. The apartments sold originally by Blue Chip did not transfer to the new developers. Subsequent to the sale of the developments, Blue Chip sold apartments for the new developers pursuant to an underwrite agreement. Deposits for these sales are held in solicitors' trust accounts,” the liquidators said. 'Investor deposits paid into the Blue Chip NZ Ltd account were probably used to fund joint venture payments, interest payments & other compensation to investors, and royalties under a supply agreement between Blue Chip NZ Ltd & Ingot Holdings Ltd. Ingot Holdings is a company associated with Mr Bryers and is outside of the Blue Chip group of companies. It was renamed Marinc Ltd and is now in liquidation.” Under Blue Chip, the Anzac Ave-Emily Place development was known as the Emily and it was to have had 149 units. Investors paid an estimated $11.2 million in deposits. Emily Projects bought the property after it was put up for mortgagee sale last July by The NZ Guardian Trust Co Ltd, owed $4.475 million. The purchase price covered the Guardian Trust debt and Guardian Trust stayed in behind ANZ Banking Group Ltd as second mortgagee on the new project. Want to comment? Email bobdey@propbd.co.nz. Attribution: Liquidators' report, land transfer documents, interview, Celerion website, story written by Bob Dey for the Bob Dey Property Report.
danny
Posted on 09-01-2012 11:33 | By ardri23
It should also be noted that Simon Power, the minister overseeing the scam, after one term in parliament, makes a shock resignation to become head of Westpac investments. Westpac and going further, General Electric finance are the ultimate lenders now foreclosing. Power was touted as a future PM! He spent years in opposition. Appeals have been made to Key, Power and co. No reply! (I know other victims as well as Margaret). Appeals have been made to Julia Gillard, Barry O'Farrell (premier of nsw) the federal police, the Australian attorney general. No action! I have contacted every media outlet in Australia. No reply! Other scams are being used now on Australian Pensioners, inviting them to an information night at a local RSL club. One such scam is called Park Trent. Same modus operandi. Recently we have petioned the Queen and the NZ Governor General, Sir Jericho Mataparae to plead for mercy and justice. We can only hope they are merciful. John Key, as many know is an erstwhile Wall Street trader, who worked for Merill Lunch, and was exclusive advisor to Alan Grenspan of the (privately owned) US Federal Reserve. I could on for hours about his involvement in this. It is a dirty dark murky trail on slimy money. And if you are silly enough to believe that PM's don't lie, well that myth was debunked on the weekend with revelations of how Muldoon lied during his time in office. Jim Bolger's fingerprints are all over this too! I have a letter with his signature on it! Wake up NZ! You are us Aussies are being fleeced by the Wall Street big boys! Maybe that's why Key does not want the tea tape made public.
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.