Beached containers: hands off

Tales of flotsam and jetsam and the lore of the sea are just that, says Maritime lawyer Piers Davies.

They are tales from the 18th and 19th centuries and have no place on modern maritime law.


Containers are falling off the stranded Rena, photographed here this morning. Photo: NZDF.

Containers that wash ashore from the wreck of the container ship Rena are still someone's property.

'The container itself will belong to a container company, the contents of the containers are people's property,” says Piers.

'The insurer of the container, the insurer of the content of the goods – they do not become the property of anybody else.

'I know this flies in the face of common knowledge, but it hasn't been the situation for probably 100 years – but there you are, folk law continues.”

New Zealand's Maritime Transport Act 1994, sections 105 and 98B are the relevant laws.

Section 105 says if a person finds or takes possession of any wreck, which in section 98B includes shipping containers, they must notify the director of Maritime New Zealand.

If they are not the owner of it they must deliver it to the police or allow police to take possession.

'Then it goes on to say every person commits an offence who without reasonable excuse fails to comply shall in addition forfeit any claim to salvage and shall be liable to pay to the owner of the wreck double the value thereof, to be recovered in the same way as a fine,” says Piers.

'I would say if it just comes ashore then you are not going to have a salvage right. If you were a fishing boat and one of these containers was floating around, and you got hold of it and brought it in to port and told MNZ, then you might have a salvage claim in these circumstances.

'I would expect MNZ to be issuing orders to everybody not to do anything except under their specific instructions.

'They won't want amateurs coming around and trying to help and get salvage claims.

They will want to keep it well under control because otherwise they will have those fantastic scenes that were down on the beach in Cornwall, of people ripping open containers and getting onto motor bikes and riding them off.”

In January 2007 the MSC Napoli was beached in Cornwall. Some of her cargo came ashore and the town of Branscombe was overrun by looters who arrived to take away anything they could carry.

'At the Napoli, the Receiver of Wrecks was walking along the shore trying to stop these people stealing them,” says Piers.

Piers Davies is a partner with Wackrow Williams and Davies Ltd, Auckland.

You may also like....

4 comments

Suze Me Sun Live....

Posted on 12-10-2011 19:37 | By Tony

Can you get some good legal advise on this clearly there is a good Weekend read on the ...Is salvage legal if how and when ???


Theft

Posted on 13-10-2011 05:48 | By Taku

The law is quite clear on this - theft by finding is still theft. If you find something, and know that there is a possibility the owner can be located, but you keep it anyway, that can be tantamount to theft.


waste not

Posted on 13-10-2011 07:53 | By dave4u

I heard that the maori party wants the seabed & foreshore act pushed thru today so they can claim the containers to use for new housing & the goods for xmas pressys


Ownership

Posted on 13-10-2011 13:19 | By Shifting sand

Typical. If the container owners are so worried about loosing their property then maybe they should get off their high horses and come pick there crap up, off our beaches. Maybe if they thought about 'our' environment instead of their wallets for a change ...... Nah, won't happen. It all boils down to money and greed.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.