Stalled action ‘sheer frustration’

The shipwreck on Astrolabe Reef is an unfolding massive ecological disaster on a scale never seen in this country, according to a source inside the operation.

The person, who we will call 'Jim” is involved in the container ship Rena salvage.


Rena has been stuck fast to Astrolabe Reef since 2.20am Wednesday - leaking oil since.

He called to speak out to SunLive exclusively and anonymously, out of 'sheer frustration”. We have agreed not to identify him.

He trusts Sun Media to put the story straight and get facts to the public that have for unknown reasons been withheld and downplayed.

'I know you guys from The Sun and Waterline Magazine and trust you can get the message out there.”

Jim says many others, including high ranking officers of several organisations involved, share his frustrations, but are afraid to speak out or have been gagged.

He says it is 'complete rubbish” that containment systems could not have been in place from day one of the incident.

'They could have had booms in place for containment and been skimming the oil since three days ago.

'The public is being placated with sugar-coated gobbledegook.”

He says many involved in the operation believe Maritime New Zealand is mainly run by 'a bunch of doddery old poms” incapable of making a decision.

'They're just sitting on their hands waiting for something to happen.”

Jim claims the official line – that weather and unsuitability of available booms prevented their use – is nonsense. The conditions could not have been more favourable.

The weather for first few days of the incident provided an opportunity for decisive action.

Jim says it is obvious even from vessels observing from outside the 1km restriction zone that there's a greater flow of oil from the damaged ship at low tide, due to differential pressure.

He believes it is only a matter of time before the ship breaks up.

'I'll bet my last dollar that ship is not coming off whole. There's only one way it's coming off that reef… in pieces.

'It's got a slight hog in it,” he says, referring to the banana shape bending, whereby the bow and stern have dropped. The mid sections are held up by the 'point loading” on the reef. The wracking and twisting continues with each tide.

SunLive's research into the topography of the reef and our discussions with experienced divers who know the reef, suggest that the stern of Rena is hanging over about 50-60m of water depth, while the touch down point on the reef appears about 50m f'ard.

Jim says the shipping company MSC is well known within the industry for its involvement with older ships with the corrosion you'd expect on vessels of this age.

The ship is wracking with the sea movement and this will only accelerate with worsening weather and swell, forecast to be three metres by Wednesday.

People have observed the containers stacked seven high on the aft deck are moving about a metre and they look likely to fall off soon.

The changing weather will also cause the oil slick to change direction, heading to the coastline with the wind.

'It's on the surface and the forecast is for nor-easters.

'That slick will be moving with the wind.”

There's 100 tonnes unaccounted for, either spilled or contained within the damaged double bottoms of the ship.

When the HFO reaches the coastline and rocks, it partially evaporates off, leaving a hard coating that will have to be 'knocked off with chisels and hammers.”

The HFO is not the only pollution concern.

The ship carries a large quantity of diesel for generators.

Also hydraulic fluid for winches machinery, pumps, and bow thrusters. This is thought to have been the source of the first slick reported on Wednesday.

Jim says people don't realise the huge effect the disaster is going to have.

'It will affect everyone in the Bay of Plenty. Particularly iwi and anyone in the marine industry and tourism.

'There's only one word to describe it. Sadness.”

You may also like....

30 comments

stalled action sheer frustration

Posted on 08-10-2011 14:17 | By algail

The shipwreck 'There's only one word to describe it. Sadness.” I could think of a lot more words and a lot saltier too.. Isn't it the NZ way to piss round in a disaster and when it's too late try to do something. One wonders how wet the bus ticket will be that they slap the master of the ship with. How can a ship run aground that has GPS charts a compass and someone on watch who like the rest of us know where the damn reef is. Alastair Bethlehem


WOW!!!

Posted on 08-10-2011 14:25 | By Jimmy51

All i can say is "thanks jim" for comirfing what everyone else already knew


Different strokes for different folks

Posted on 08-10-2011 14:42 | By jumpar

Isn't it interesting that EBOP haven't jumped on hard to Maritime NZ. I have worked in the marine industry and slight deisel spills are treated as huge threat with need for dispersents to be released and booms available on call. So why hasn't this happened for a full blown oil spill. Conditions were choppy initially but a boom I'm sure would have stopped some or slowed it down. Shame on you EBOP get your control back!


WHY DO US GOOD PEOPLE PUT UP WITH ****** ??

Posted on 08-10-2011 14:48 | By Demandthetruth

You may have noted my 3 blogs to this site the first being the first day. Everything I have said is coming true. Good one Jim lets get more so we can whack a few for negligence. I trust we have at least charged (at least 8 charges) the Captain or has he left NZ already? The vascillation by Govt bodies MNZ, EBOP,TCC & the Owners will cause us all tens of millions$ in losses. Well PM we may as well start the Commission of Inquiry now while its all fresh in our minds & lets have it in Tauranga. Oh by the way I believe there is 1 Chinook in NZ!!


good on yer

Posted on 08-10-2011 14:48 | By pomfart

Give "Jim" a medal. Time to dispose of the doddery old poms and get some kiwi can do up and running. Get some No 8 wire "Jim" and make some booms. Then suck up the oil with a straw. Simple as. Then tie some No 8 wire together to lift the containers off or they're going to topple in the drink. Come on "Jim", get stuck in, there's no time to waste. Just do something, anything. First though "Jim", pop the jug on and get the old poms a nice cuppa. They've got some important mulling over to do to ensure brain donors like you don't muck it up.


Tourism to be dead...

Posted on 08-10-2011 15:08 | By dgk

Probably wont be any action until the oil hits the Mount Main Beach....and then it will be far to late to save the tourism industry.


Some balance...

Posted on 08-10-2011 15:15 | By wreck1080

You need to hear 2 sides to the story. Jim put his case forward, now , i'd like to hear the other side. All I can see, is that they are planning for a disaster rather than prevention of one.


Speaking Up

Posted on 08-10-2011 15:19 | By sandyshore

Well done Jim, someone has to speak out for those that can't. If our marine mammals & birds could talk they would be demanding action NOW & I'm sure they wouldn't mind what nationality mucks in to help. But all we are getting is they have a plan A & we have a plan B & C depending on weather & Rena's hull condition. Well that's all well & good but when are we going to see the salvage work begin? I couldn't go for my walk along Papamoa Beach today as I can't bear to see the site of that ship out there whilst I'm still angry & saddened. Better make sure it's not just a wet bus ticket punishment Mr Joyce & Mr Key, huh ??!!


Thank you Sun Live

Posted on 08-10-2011 15:24 | By Openknee8ted

and thank you Jim


Poms

Posted on 08-10-2011 15:25 | By tabatha

True to the meaning of the name, prisioners of mother england, they still hold a grudge for having been slung out of their country for pilfering a loaf of bread. (Study history to find out what I mean.) I have noticed for years that we seem to have had and apparently still have engineers etc that have an extraction from England, in the old days we said the mother country, but now our make is more than that. If what Jim days is true, and I do not doubt it, when the time for the inquiry comes, and there will be one, all governments do it after a disaster, I hope Jim and his mates are able to speak out and the ones who have sat on their hands are suitably fixed, perhaps sent back to their homeland, and lets us pick up the pieces and hope to get our part of the world back into order. If what we know and think will happen that could take many years and our children and grandchildren may be able once again enjoy the beautiful Bay of Plenty. Just a thought those senior pupils who are now on holiday may be able to help with some of the coastal work when the need arises. They are far fitter than us oldies though I know if the need arises we will be there as well. Now the beans have been spilt action is needed and this Sunlive page needs to be flashed to all of importance around the country. Thank you Sunlive for being like your name live and willing to publish peoples thoughts.


Wake up dreamers.

Posted on 08-10-2011 16:06 | By waitandwatch

This is what happens when man challenges mother nature. Trust me, the worst is yet to came. What is happening around the world is reaching NZ shores. This is deja vu for some of us. Do not think NZ is safe anymore. the world is watching and we need to be more, much more proactive. What will happen when the worst comes in. Till then do we sit and wait. No those in responsible positions need to act. where is the local MP. the victims underwater need to be supported. we are answerable to them.


Tabby dear

Posted on 08-10-2011 16:06 | By pomfart

You've noticed "engineers that have an extraction from England"?? Weird. No Poms are in NZ for being "slung out" of mother England and none ever were. I haven't studied it but I don't think NZ was a penal colony? I doubt any would be sent back. Most Poms in NZ are highly educated. They invited here to bring expertise and raise up the IQ level because of illiterate fools like you. Study English to improve your grammar. I could barely follow your nonsensical ramblings.


Shafted

Posted on 08-10-2011 16:20 | By Papamoa

We will be shafted in this debacle. The Shipping Company will say all the right things , not take full responsibility, get a PR company ( not mine ) to put a spin on it. Why do they care , its not in their backyard . Listen people THEY DO NOT CARE!!!!


Surprised - No!

Posted on 08-10-2011 16:39 | By Jitter

When you have hudreds of millions of tonnes of cargo and hundreds of ships moving in and out of a port like Tauranga you can expect an accident like this occaisionallly. It all comes down to human error. As we know these do occur, frequently in many walks of life. HOWEVER I would have also expected the necessary equipment to combat such a disaster permanently in storage at one of our major ports (Wellington as it is central) by Maritime NZ. You cannot place the blame for inaction on TCC (out of their area of responsibility) or EBOP (who are obviously running around in ever decreasing circles and don't know where to start, as it is really not their ballgame either). Maritime NZ should have procedures and equipment in place for just such an eventuality. However they appear to be as well organised and up with the play as Civil Defence aren't. There are about 150 personnel on site in Tauranga now to deal with the problem but don't seem to have done very much yet. Unless the ship devlops a drastic list or the sea gets up and there is a lot of movement containers should be ok as they are held on by strong twist locks at each corner. However in extreme conditions these will snap. I guess the major problem is the possibility of the ship breaking in two and then we will be in real deep trouble. Best of luck to all who really are working on a solution to this problem. I don't believe it has become a disaster YET.


Jim'll Fix It

Posted on 08-10-2011 16:47 | By pomfart

Who is this "Jim"? Have Sunlive checked his credentials? How high ranking is he? Either NZ is full of racist idiots if "Jim" is to be believed ("many involved in the operation believe Maritime New Zealand is mainly run by 'a bunch of doddery old poms” incapable of making a decision) or "Jim" is a lone nutter. It's staggering how many fools think he or she is talking sense.


What a joke!

Posted on 08-10-2011 16:55 | By Yasmine

What a joke, why hasn't the oil been cleaned up? Enough of plan a and plan b..... Just get the job done! It has been four days, stop pissing around. What's the hold up? The first sign of oil is when the clean up should have started, there's no time to waste. Stop this disaster from killing our marine mammels,birds and beautiful coast.


Blame the Poms

Posted on 08-10-2011 17:00 | By Glen Clova

Poor old tabatha been on the turps again


Afraid?

Posted on 08-10-2011 17:03 | By sojourner

Afraid of what? Or who? And why?


I'm with Jim

Posted on 08-10-2011 17:04 | By Kin

I too am a high ranking official involved in this operation. My real name is not Kin though as I don't want my stupidity to be revealed. Jim is right, those Poms are incapable of doing anything. God only knows how they brought the world steam power, flush toilets, supersonic transport, radio and TV to name a few. My idea is to move all the containers to the back so that the front tips up, then Jim can fix his No 8 wire to the bow and swivel it off the rocks. Those damned Poms won't let us though. I'm very frustrated by this and thought the best thing to do is show my ignorance to everyone.


its only Tauranga

Posted on 08-10-2011 17:14 | By The author of this comment has been removed.

can you imagine if this happened on Auckland's front doorstep? heaven forbid, if a container ship ran into rangitoto or bean rock. the officials would be tripping over their lattes to get this disgusting fuel muck pumped, pronto. lucky eh, it's just little ol Tauranga, so unimportant in the scheme of things that it doesnt even warrant a rugby match. Bureaucratic boofheads.


Dads army

Posted on 08-10-2011 17:26 | By blackcat

good on ya Jim, tell it as it is. most people have been suspecting this anyway. at least someone has the balls to speak up. You're right about MNZ and in fact a lot of these archaic authorities are the same, run by tired old codgers. Just take a look at the outdated and ineffectual water safety lot. Dads Army.you'd think that NZ's largest port would have all this oil gear stationed and ready, for offshore islands not just little harbour spillages. its all about profit for these shipping companies, they need to be levied to ensure the gear is good enough to cover such horrific eventualities.


I say it again!

Posted on 08-10-2011 18:08 | By Zara

I agree ! Posted on 07-10-2011 13:27 | By Zara We should slow it down as much as possible,call in every expert under the sun and let it develop into a major disaster. We will then have something really worthwhile to manage. Then when its all over call for a national enquiry costing millions of dollars to come to the conclusion we should have acted with more haste from the outset and that no one was actually responsible for the shambolic outcome, but we have all learnt lessons from this and will try to do much better next time.


To the Pom resistance and Turps Lover

Posted on 08-10-2011 21:24 | By tabatha

Kirrie, have not touched a drop and to the person/s re poms coming to NZ. I believe that those who were sent to Australia were after a time had served sentence and came across to NZ, so poms did come to NZ. The important part here is the Great Britain engineers to be precise did become lords of their job and thought they were invincible. The need to for action is now showing and thank goodness for that. Once the start is made we getting towards the end, and as it has been said by many the start seemed slow. In defence of the workers you do need the tools to operate with and there are times when they may seem easy to get but in the cased of the barge it had to be emptied first before use. Let us all get behind the rescue effort and hope like hang a major disaster can be averted. Wishful but thoughtful thinking.


conspiracy theory.

Posted on 08-10-2011 22:07 | By CC8

Maybe the captain was ordered to run the Rena on the rocks at Astrolabe.... or somewhere equally convenient , so that the company could collect the insurance and find another ship which does not have the rust issues and record with the Aussie authorities. Lets face it if she went back to Aussie the Rena might get stuck in port and written off!! Too expensive to repair to Aussie standards!! Astrolabe is nice and close to port,nice weather , seas were calm , so little physical danger to the captain (never mind the crew), best place to do it , where the authorities are uncoordinated ineffectual and indecisive, so little danger of any real consequences..... or maybe this idea is simply a candidate for NOT THE NEWS :-)


excellent article

Posted on 08-10-2011 23:17 | By Salty SeaDog

I wish other media talked and questioned like this article does instead of just printing the governments sugarcoating nonsense


WHAT WE SEE SO FAR IS ....

Posted on 09-10-2011 01:55 | By MISS ADVENTURE

Maritime NZ, no where to be seen. Salvager, little happening, most likely cos Maritime NZ is in the way. Bent Ship means the pressure is on for each and every tide. Good weather so far, no meaningful effort to get the fuel off, clean up the mess before bad weather arrives. Remember Katrina; well mark my words this mess is of the same "official" mess and all the media drivel will be applied to cover up why it was a mess. Where is RBOP, this is an environmental issue of a rather large scale and they are silent, what are they doing to protect our shoreline and the sea environment? Simple answers: - 1 Get a Boat or barge out there with a hose and pump and pump off all the fuel, diesel that can. 2 Get the one and only heavy lift chopper up from Taupo and start moving containers off the time is about 15-20 minutes round trip to Motiti Is, that means in a 12 hour day 35-40 containers can be moved, the risky ones are at the back and on the port side. 3 There are about 10-12 heavy lift choppers in Aussie, get a 3-4 over here ASAP, they will need to be sat on the deck of a Trans-Tasman ship, they will be here in 3 days. That would mean that 150-170 containers a day can be moved off the ship. 4 There are some containers on board that are a hazard and need to be removed before they end up in the sea, they are a priority to remove off the ship. 5 Make some plan to get the ship repaired a bit to drag it off the rocks after the containers are off. If the above does not happen then some heads need to roll, I mean all of them from top to bottom need to have the arse on the line for sitting by and nothing happens. We do have the ability to remedy this, we do have the tech, the know-how-can-do ... and above all else NZ is meant to be an environmental strong hold. So why is nothing happening here?


We need this bureaucracy like a hole in a ship

Posted on 09-10-2011 09:37 | By SpeakUp

I looked up this 'bunch of doddery old poms incapable of making a decision”. You can see their smiley faces here: http://www.maritimenz.govt.nz/About-us/MNZ-Director-and-Authority-profiles.asp MNZ is made up of a Board of five members appointed by the Governor General on the recommendation of the Minister of Transport, Steven Joyce. Maritime New Zealand has independent statutory powers under the Maritime Transport Act 1994. This bureaucratic machine has totally failed its purpose and HEADS SHOULD ROLL. We pay these bureaucrats mega dollars but they are not only totally useless but actually hinder effective action. The public has also a right to learn of the investigation of the accident. What has the captain to say? Has prosecution started? The conspiracy theory of CC8 makes hellish sense.


Very Slick

Posted on 09-10-2011 10:07 | By makkas

The Government stepped in quick enough when the Auckland heads of departments (that get paid vulgar amouints of money)got it wrong with the Rugby World Cup . . . What are they doing to make sure all resources are available to clean up this looming mess? People . . . PUT PRESSURE ON PARLIAMENT TODAY . . . FIX IT NOW!!!!!!


national incompetence again?

Posted on 09-10-2011 16:57 | By Rayna

It is difficult to imagine any other country in the world with a potential marine disaster vacillating the way NZ has. Is permission required before basic steps are taken? MNZ and every associated so-called expert are reprehensible for their non action in this matter. Offers from NZ proven experts in the field (made inside 48 hours of the grounding) have apparently also been ignored. What does it take for common sense to prevail? Rayna


@ RAYNA

Posted on 10-10-2011 08:33 | By PLONKER

To many officials have there greasy little fingers all over the decision making process hence nothing happens until after it is a complete and utter mess, the owners are on the other side of the world somewhere and likely don't give a rats as it is not the US so can not get ya BUTT SUED off, so business as usual.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.