The Kiwifruit Claim class action by 212 growers and a post-harvest operator will go to the High Court next year, seeking $400 million in damages from the government.
The case alleges negligence in letting the vine disease Psa into New Zealand in 2010, but an initial judgment on the substantive points may not be available until mid-2017.
The deadline for growers to join the claim was October 9. Photo: File.
By last Friday's deadline, growers representing 32 per cent of the total gold kiwifruit crop as at 2009/10 and 13 per cent of the green crop had signed the claim.
'The growers who have signed up to the claim estimate they alone have suffered losses of $376.4 million as a result of the outbreak,” says Kiwifruit Claim spokesman Matthew Hooton.
'We expect the Treasury will need to include the claim as a contingent liability in the December Economic and Fiscal Update being prepared now.
'The Kiwifruit Claim believes we have a good chance of success.
'We allege that the government was negligent when it let a specific shipment of anthers from a Psa-ravaged part of China into New Zealand, and that this negligence is what caused the losses to kiwifruit growers during the subsequent outbreak across the country.
'The government denies that direct connection. It also denies that its decision to let in the anthers from an infected part of China was negligent and even denies it owes a duty of care to growers in protecting our country from pests and diseases anyway.”
Neil Trebilco, president of NZ Kiwifruit Growers Inc says New Zealand has a total of 2500 growers and, in the 2009/2010 season, post-harvest operator Seeka – an early signatory to the claim – would have accounted for around 25 per cent of the total crop.
'NZKGI always believed the legal action would take a very long time and has advised growers to seek legal advice before signing up,” says Neil.
'But in the end it was a decision for growers to make whether or not to be involved. We know Psa has cost growers a lot and have always recognised that.”
Neil says the impact of Psa has taught the industry and the government a big lesson. 'We all need to do better,” he says.
NZKGI is pleased to see increased measures put in place to tighten border security, including x-ray of luggage, more detector dogs and increased surveillance for cruise ship passengers.
Matthew says those taking the action think the government does have a legal duty of care to growers.
'As well as its obvious moral and political duty to all New Zealanders to take the utmost care when protecting our country's agriculture and unique native flora and fauna from foreign pests, it should be accountable through the courts when it carries out its critical biosecurity role.”
The High Court set October 9 as the final date for growers to join the claim, after confirming the claim meets all of the requirements to proceed as a class action and approved the litigation funder and the funding arrangements.



5 comments
Not my taxes please
Posted on 21-10-2015 10:22 | By BullShtAlert
I don't want my taxes potentially paying out kiwifruit growers. I want a straight answer to this question: did any growers or kiwifruit marketing people ever visit contaminated orchards overseas?
BullShtAlert
Posted on 21-10-2015 12:39 | By hakihana
Yep totally agree with you!
Pure Greed
Posted on 21-10-2015 12:50 | By Bop man
it is a result of the kiwi fruit industry just trying to make more and more money no matter the cost. Well it has come and bit them in the rear end big time. No one to blame but the industry itself....
Very Clear
Posted on 21-10-2015 13:46 | By Gigilo
This is a Chinese Gooseberry and a new fleet of BMW's for the LLB.
Bop man
Posted on 21-10-2015 19:43 | By Plonker
Actually cuttings were imported and were able to snuck through border controls easily, that is the real issue, Government needs to take border control VERY seriously
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.