Ship rent debate on hold

Debate over rent paid by Marine Reach's vessel Pacific Hope is on hold after councillors discovered there is already a deal in operation that is not mentioned in the staff report.

Councillor John Robson called off the debate over whether the ship should be ‘adopted' by the city when he learned the ship is already paying half rent because of an unrecorded agreement.

Marine Reach's vessel Pacific Hope is at the centre of a rent row.

The staff report states an agreement was made between the council and Marine Reach in August 2013, that it would pay half the normal fee for a berth on the slip jetty. It means the charity that operates the ship pays about $2000 a month instead of $4000.

But staff were unable to answer John's question about who made the earlier agreement to pay 50 per cent of the normal amount, and whether the council was being asked to reduce the normal rate by 50 per cent, or the rate that the ship is currently paying.

Chairman Steve Morris accepted his resolution that council leave it until the next meeting. Mayor Stuart Crosby, who is also patron of Marine Reach, stood down during the discussion.

Pacific Hope's skipper Jesse Misa also took issue with the contents of the report. Speaking after the meeting he challenges the assertion the Pacific Hope, at 480 tonnes and 54.1m length overall, is too large for the finger jetty.

The jetty was originally built as part of the 600-tonne slip structure, says Jesse. And he says Pacific Hope is lighter and presents less windage than Mark Scapens' barge and two storey accommodation block moored astern of the Pacific Hope.

'Some of the information that is given is incorrect concerning the size of the vessel,” says Jesse. 'The big structure behind us is much bigger and heavier than us. It's much heavier in volume and it will have more windage.”

He says the wharfage issue is because while the ship which takes up 60 metres alongside, it is perched on the end of the wharf with only 20 metres at the stern actually alongside the wharf. The bow lines are on the mooring dolphin, some metres north of the wharf.

'You see we have had much bigger ships there before,” adds Jesse. 'The Island Mercy was 900-tonnes and that wharf has been improved now, so in a way the information was incorrect.”

The Pacific Hope is undergoing a refit and is expected to embark on a voyage around the Pacific Islands in June, providing eye care and dental operations.

Marine Reach is seeking free berthage for the Pacific Hope until June 30, 2015, while also seeking the city's help with storage.

It has been based in Tauranga for 24 years and in that time has served over 400,000 people with medical, dental and optometry services in over 18 nations.

In addition to reduced or free berthage Marine Reach is seeking free or low-cost storage for supplies and it wants the city council to adopt the ship as an expression of the city's humanitarian support into the Pacific.

You may also like....

9 comments

Merit

Posted on 18-11-2014 08:44 | By YOGI BEAR

far better case than any hairy fairy statures or art gallery, chop them and provide this service, a much better option.


No more deals

Posted on 18-11-2014 09:24 | By BullShtAlert

I'm amazed that the council would even consider giving any group a cheap or free deal for berthage. This is a religious organisation and it should be up to its members and god to provide, not ratepayers. Charity should be up to individual choice and not forced upon us by Councils. Of course Marine Reach wants council to "adopt" it because it means cheap or free rent. Every person, group and organisation needs to pay their fair share. Nothing is free. I'm gobsmacked that there is already a half rent deal going on that councillors didn't know about and isn't mentioned in the report. Someone needs to be held accountable. This Council must have too much money?


compassionate council?

Posted on 18-11-2014 09:32 | By peecee09

What a wonderful service they provide to our Pacific neighbours. Council should offer free berthage and not even consider debating the option.


Everyone......

Posted on 18-11-2014 09:40 | By Jimmy Ehu

wants something for nothing, if you do not like our charges, try Gisborne, or even Motiti, I would rather ratepayers gave the Waipuna Hospice more support.


Pacific Islands mmmmmmmm

Posted on 18-11-2014 14:28 | By CC8

New Zealand is a group of Pacific Islands, and it has poor people here who cannot afford dental care, perhaps they should think about something in exchange while the ship is berthed here. I am sure Tauranga Work and Income has a bunch of clients who could do with some dental care, which does not consist of "rip it out" we can afford to fix it..


Will it ever stop ...

Posted on 18-11-2014 14:35 | By Murray.Guy

Thank you, John Robson, thank you! This highlights concerns I've raised for years in regards the integrity of processes and outcomes, selective advice provided by staff in agenda and public documents, the deals behind closed doors and in the shadows. Will ANYONE be held to account for choosing NOT to disclose the truth in the staff report, will a staff member no longer employed be used as a scape goat. We have known for some time the desire of Mayor Crosby to waive berth fees, recalling an approach to councillors for support in the privacy of the 'councillors lounge' and rejected 18 months back! Mayor Crosby declares an interest and doesn't participate, and doesn't have to. Seems he may have already done a deal under the table!


Marine Reach

Posted on 18-11-2014 14:40 | By Murray.Guy

Marine Reach are an absolutely amazing organisation and cannot in any way be held responsible for processes and attitudes of others. They would NOT be paying half owed in rent, accruing a mountain of debt to the ratepayer, without a misguided confidence that integrity was being applied to Council processes. I suspect that the Mayor may not be alone with a 'conflict of interest' in the Chambers!


Fund Waipuna Hospice instead.

Posted on 18-11-2014 15:03 | By dgk

While TCC is considering this freebie, I hope they consider full funding to an even better organisation. That is, Waipuna Hospice.


I Think

Posted on 18-11-2014 21:48 | By Capt_Kaveman

this lot including crew just want to go for a free ride on the donations of others, there is so much more that could be done within NZ than worry about the islands, We or NZ let x amount in already and 95% prob end up on our benefit system anyhow, NZ does enough already


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.