Resident's faecal shower concerns

A Mount Maunganui man says he is getting short shrift from Air New Zealand when he asks how one of its planes came to shower his wife in something smelling strongly of human excrement.

Mike McCarthy's wife Marion was having lunch on the patio of the couple's Hibiscus Avenue home on Saturday when a plane flew overhead – followed by a brief, smelly shower.


Mike McCarthy inspects suspicious specks on his barbecue cover.

'As it came over this stuff came down from the aeroplane. Little globules of stuff and both my neighbour and my wife, she got it over herself and over her clothes. She washed them all and noticed a very strong excrement smell.”

The five by five metre patio was liberally sprinkled, as was the table, the food and Marion, who immediately showered, and continued to complain about the strong smell, says Mike.

They photographed the droplets and wrapped the food before storing it. Mike then tried to contact Air NZ but is frustrated with their lack of response.

'I've been trying to get hold of Air NZ, I rang the manager here, they just do not want to know anything about it. I said ‘Come and have a look' but he says they are not bothered, not interested.

'I've contacted CAA [Civil Aviation Authority] and they are looking at it. I've rung Air NZ in Auckland. They are saying it couldn't be from an aeroplane.”

The suspect aircraft is a Bombadier Q300 on climb-out from Tauranga en route to Auckland. Air NZ flight NZ8230 departed Tauranga terminal for Auckland on Saturday about 12.45pm, which would place it over Hibiscus Ave a few minutes later, depending how long it took to taxi out to the end of the runway.

Mike says the plane flew over their home at 12.55pm.

Both the CAA and Air NZ have suggested to Mike the shower was most likely from overhead ducks – a common seasonal occurrence.

Mike is rubbishing the thought, saying he has spent many years hunting and knows what duck poo smells like.

'I contacted Environment BOP [now the Bay of Plenty Regional Council]. They don't want to know anything about because they don't control the air.”

Mike believes a similar incident happened last week on Oceanbeach Road.

CAA contact manager corporate communications Mike Richards says there is definitely a seasonal element to the complaint. It is the time of year when ducks fly high, he says.

'And they do unfortunately offload. It happens every year.

'We are just checking to make sure it's not an isolated occurrence. If it is, then obviously that makes it something else. If there are a number of these have been happening then it's probably quite consistent with the seasonal issue.

'We are just checking these [complaints] out now. I believe he kept some residue. We are definitely following that through to make sure there is nothing to be concerned about.”

He says the complaint will be treated like an aviation related concern, and followed up to make sure there is no residing problem.

'The issue for us is if there is something wrong with an aircraft we want to get it fixed.”


Remnants of what Mike believes is faecal matter dropped from an overhead Air NZ flight.

9 comments

showers

Posted on 12-11-2013 14:08 | By gingerpussy

This happens more often than people think. Wouldnt you think that the aircrafts would wait till they are above the ocean to let this go......


Why..!!

Posted on 12-11-2013 14:13 | By Ness

Why doesn't someone just go to the this man's house and get some of the "stuff" that fell from the sky and have it examined. I'm sure the bloke would have known if ducks were flying over head. Don't you just get sick of being fobbed off because those in "authority" simply can't be bothered with what they probably think, is something trivial?!!


Poor Air New Zealand

Posted on 12-11-2013 15:18 | By The author of this comment has been removed.

Maybe it is going to hit the fan after all. . .


I'm no expert in poo

Posted on 12-11-2013 15:23 | By Annalist

But a simple solution could be to have the samples analysed at a laboratory. They could probably tell the difference.


Simple really???

Posted on 12-11-2013 15:47 | By penguin

Surely the way to test the origin of the "stuff" would simply be to have it analysed professionally. Not too difficult is it? I am sure there is a distinct difference between human and duck ‘poo.'


Wear It

Posted on 12-11-2013 16:37 | By Disappointed

Given that Air NZ is majority state owned they are only following the example set by their owners and doing to Mr & Mrs McCarthy what the government have been doing to the rest of New Zealand these last few years.


Don't think so.

Posted on 12-11-2013 20:30 | By CW

The editorial says this is a plane leaving Tauranga and going to Auckland....this is only a 30 minute flight at worse...I doubt that anyone at all uses the on-board toilet for "Number 2's" in that short time, let alone enough people to fill it up! Especially given that it is only just taking off and everyone is in their seat anyway. LOL! I'm with the "Duck-Poo" option.


Agree

Posted on 13-11-2013 08:29 | By RawPrawn

Just get the deposits tested. I'm also curious as to whay an aircraft en route to Auckland (North) would turn right (South) after taking off from Tauranga, to be anywhere near Hibiscus Avenue? Or is that a common practice for traffic departing from Tauranga Airport?


Analysis is the answer.

Posted on 13-11-2013 22:16 | By morepork

I'm thinking this is unlikely to be from an aircraft (they don't normally discharge their toilets in the air unless there is a malfunction, and if there was, it would be accompanied by the blue liquid used to sterilize.) There are numerous recorded incidents of "blue ice" from aircraft with toilet malfunctions at very high altitude; this one was low enough that there would be no ice, but there would still be "blue". The really simple resolution of the matter is to have the samples analysed. If Air NZ PR had any brains they would have rushed to do this just to clear themselves. Instead, they alienate the people concerned and show how little they care about the rest of us. It would serve them right if it DOES prove to have come from their plane...


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.