Council spends $3.4m on consultants

The Bay of Plenty Regional Council spent $3.4million on consultants in the last financial year - but that's less than the previous two years.

According to figures released to SunLive under the Official Information Act the regional council spent more than $500,000 less on consultants in the last year, compared with 2010.


Bay of Plenty Regional Council offices in Mount Maunganui.

It spent $3,924,753 in 2010, $3,444,660 in 2011 and $3,419,789 in the last year ending June 30.

Regional council CEO Mary Anne McLeod says consultant costs for the current year are expected to come in on budget and to be less than the previous financial year.

'I'm pretty sure that the budget has come down again for next year,”

'I'm pushing quite hard to get it down and council is pushing quite hard as well. I think what we will be looking for is efficiencies in terms of can we do more.”

The council hires consultants for a variety of reasons, to cover peaks in terms of staff demand, or to supply technical advice.

'Quite often we need technical advice and that's where we tend to be using the technical scientists, the lawyers, those sort of people. It just doesn't make sense to have them internally.

'We have had a lot of that in the last little while working on the lakes programme. Or you need a team working on it, not necessarily one person but a whole lot of skills coming together.

'We also tend to use them where we have a peak of work coming through where we don't think it's appropriate to bring in a permanent person.”

Consultants are hired to work in resource consent areas, pollution prevention, or when there is an influx of people seeking water consents by a statutory deadline.

Mary Anne also says consultants are hired when there have been council policy changes and council staff have to suddenly deal with a lot of work in a particular area.

'Often that's rechargeable and we can get that money back,” says Mary Anne.

'The Rena did have a bit of an impact on us. We are still working with Government on that. We have managed to recoup a lot of our costs, but a lot still falls on us because of our responsibilities.

'Because we have got responsibility for navigation safety, even though what we were doing was way in excess of what we were normally doing, the exclusion zones and that sort of thing, it's still considered our function so we are still in debate slightly looking at if we can recoup some of those costs.”

Consultants are also used where the council has to deal with larger long term issues, or reviewing longer term strategy programmes where an outside perspective can assist.

'They are quite useful to get a flavour you can't get in the bay, or because you are embedded in the organisation – that's where you need that more global national perspective - to get an outside view or to get some independence.”

The amount spent on consultants dealing with sustainable coastal management has increased from $55,800 in 2011 to $179,781 in 2012, partly due to the risk assessment review work of Tauranga Harbour.

Sustainable regional development work has increased from $247,747 in 2011 to $591,782 in 2012, with a large proportion of these costs reimbursed by various public agencies.

Corporate services consultancy increased from under half a million dollars in 2011, from $412,209 to $758,762 in 2012.

Mary Anne says some of this will be due to the three year cycle of preparing the regional Ten Year Plan, and covering for some staff vacancies.

More than 300 different suppliers were engaged by the council in 2010/11.

The following table identifies a list of consultants by activity for the last three years.

Activity
30 June 2010 30 June 2011 Year to Date 2012
Governance & Accountability $381,051 $234,799 $185,488
Strategic Policy $612,840 $725,136 $725,136
Sustainable Communities $372,927 $265,529 $291,132
Sustainable Land Management $150,417 $199,279 $132,146
Sustainable Water Management $537,545 $205,088 $98,132
Sustainable Coastal Management $99,357 $55,857 $179,781
Sustainable Air Management
$126,152 $239,093 $148,278
Resource Regulation $170,884 $152,193 $80,509
Regional Monitoring
$96,376 $12,667 $16,182
Sustainable Transport
$135,266 $72,595 $12,158
Sustainable Regional Development $99,011 $ 247,747 $591,782
Rivers, Drainage & Flood Management $623,575 $622,467 $251,941
Corporate Services $519,352 $412,209 $758,762

Consultancy costs by programme for the year ended 30 June 2011:

Governance Service: Rating review - $100,426.

Organisational Planning: Preparation of 10 Year Plan - $134,373.

Statutory Policy: Preparation of Regional Policy Statement, Coastal Environmental and District Plans - $200,077.

Non Statutory Policy: Lake Rotorua wetland feasibility study and intervention packages - $338,353.

Transport Planning: Preparation of transport improvement, impacts of regional growth and freight study reports - $186,706.

Recreation and Open Spaces: Cultural monitoring, archaeological work and meeting fees - $14,061.

Māori Engagement: Iwi management plans - $61,459.

Communications: Backyard publication - $120,994.

Environmental Education: Resource development - $39,871.

Civil Defence & Emergency Management: BOP lifeline - $28,623.

Sustainable Land Management: Community support programmes - $53,304

Biodiversity: Kiwi management programmes - $44,786.

Biosecurity: Biological control programmes for wallabies and wild conifers - $101,188.

Sustainable Water: Regional groundwater and geothermal field management - $45,328

Rotorua Lakes: Land use strategies and wall monitoring - $159,760.

Sustainable Coastal: Archaeological work, communications assistance and resource management work - $7,693.

Maritime Operations: Port and harbour safety plans - $48,164.

Rotorua Air: Rating postponement policy and incentive campaign. Preparation of audits of suppliers - $239,093.

Resource Consents: Consultants engaged for consents - generally recoverable from applicant - $60,145.

Pollution Prevention: Contaminated site investigation - recoverable from the Crown -$92,048.

Natural Environment Regional Monitoring: Data and geothermal management advice -$12,667.

Tauranga Passenger Transport: Passenger service planning review - $30,785.

Regional Passenger Transport: Passenger service and best practices review - $41,810.

Regional Economic Development: Regional strategic development including aqua cultural, forestry development, and regional readiness report - $244,652.

Kaituna Catchment: $15,657.

Rangitāiki-Tarawera Rivers Scheme: Matahina Dam re-consenting reports and advice - $179,358.

Whakatāne Waimana Rivers Scheme: $6,977.

Waioeka-Otara Rivers Scheme: $4,143

Engineering Advice & Non Scheme Works: Advice relating to ÅŒkere Gates, diversion options and flood forecasting - $416,334.

Land & Buildings and Vehicles: Advice on rent reviews and building valuations - $16,921.

Treasury and Rates: Investment advisory services - $88,779.

Finance: Tax compliance review and advice - $97,393.

Property & Procurement: Catering services and implementation of procurement system - $63,047.

Information Services/ Technology: Information technology consultancy - $50,029.

Human Resources: Remuneration policy and training plan development - $95,796.

Unbudgeted consultancy costs incurred for CV Rena work are being recovered from the Ministry for the Environment.

The BOPRC has 277,100 residents and spends more on consultants than the Waikato Regional Council with 390,000 residents – but neither is in the same league as the Greater Wellington Regional Council with 473,000 residents and a consultants' bill last year of $22.1million.

20 comments

Anyone

Posted on 30-07-2012 13:38 | By Butch

Can be a consultant, this city is full of them, all feeding at the Council trough, all shuffling paper, and all talking rubbish, to get another contract, and here was I thinking the Council had its own experts for this crap, and I really do not care about comparisons with other centres, its this city that I care about, and the extreme rates we pay, and what we get for our dollar.


Question time

Posted on 30-07-2012 14:04 | By bigted

Work for a council? Want to justify your position? Want to avoid making decisions? Want to cover thy butt? Then hire a consultant!


Gotta keep their chums happy

Posted on 30-07-2012 14:18 | By SpeakUp

Shameless blatant cronyism! I can virtually hear the snorting of snouts in the trough: rort rort rort...


In defense....

Posted on 30-07-2012 14:33 | By wreck1080

Some jobs you need consultants where you need some expertise. The trick is trying to determine whether a consultant is really needed for a given problem. eg, if you have in-house IT staff, then, why would you need external IT consultants? Unless it were for a particularly challenging project outside the expertise of current staff. The trend of declining use of consultants is encouraging.


.

Posted on 30-07-2012 15:01 | By traceybjammet

why on earth do they need a rates consultant, they just put them up to pay the consultant?? Corporate services?? thats a loose description? I think we in NZ are going to have to start working backwards. Give these morons a budget and tell them to work within the budget not just spend with no responsibility. It appears they are not answerable to anyone common-sense might be needed and if you have kids forget IT etc be a consultant or a lawyer thats where the money is Also is there an independent body that audits these people??


What a crock

Posted on 30-07-2012 15:32 | By The Sage

Bureaucracy gone mad. I guess some of this money for organizational planning and development has gone to Priority One and the Chamber of Commerce. Who are most likely also funded for the sustainable regional development. Give us a break. I am still waitIng to see some proven results from these organizations who keep bleating on about what they intend to do and claiming others successes as their own. Jobs for the boys. What did a Priority One staff member have to show us after a trip to China earlier this year with a group of In Step educators? Does anyone know the point of that exercise? Isf someone does could they please enlighten me.


Mrs Gadgette

Posted on 30-07-2012 16:46 | By Gadgette

Can I get a job as a consultant. Very capable in many areas.


TRACEY B JAMMET

Posted on 30-07-2012 17:01 | By PLONKER

A 'rates consultant' is certainly required, so as to plan for, scheme up and implement new and more cunning ways to extract money from ratepayers, pretty bad really on that front, like nothing changes.


lol

Posted on 30-07-2012 20:03 | By Capt_Kaveman

and what do we end up with bad designed streets roads roundabouts crap traffic lights infact this whole city is just a shambles


Sustainable water management

Posted on 30-07-2012 20:23 | By lpm67

Gee I know a bloke who does this in the lower north island and gets paid $70,000...much cheaper than these consultancy fees!!!And what exactly is meant by corporate services....wouldnt that be their support staff????


Sustainable Coastal Management

Posted on 30-07-2012 21:52 | By PLONKER

$179,781, shouldn't this be biled to Iwi as they own all the beaches now?


Hell Plonker

Posted on 31-07-2012 06:00 | By Butch

you cannot do that, a Pakeha asking the Iwi for money, shock horror!!!!


Council Excuses

Posted on 31-07-2012 13:43 | By jayjay

What's New!


HELL YES BUTCH

Posted on 31-07-2012 14:34 | By PLONKER

I know it willl be a challenge to actually get the money but it would be fun just to do it anyway!


LPM67

Posted on 06-08-2012 02:58 | By YOGI

Agreed, and this is the tip of the iceberg.


Council RORT alright

Posted on 07-08-2012 20:49 | By Can do it

It is impossible to get common sense from council staff, THAT must be why we the landowners etc MUST foot the LAND TAX bill cunningly called rates these days to keep the same fools in the same cushy jobs while they duck shove the responsibility on exorbitantly priced consultants.I would like to be consulted on why they take my land tax and will NOT come up and reopen the road for me to get home!! Waste of time consulting Council - Inroads, They simply are not interested !!


CAN DO IT

Posted on 10-08-2012 12:50 | By TERMITE

Yes, the costs are huge, the consultants are paid way to much especially when you allow for the the fact that in most cases Council already employs a raft of staff with qualifications and on big salaries and some as well, seems a bit silly to have all of these staff keeping a seat warmer than warm and cozy yet mega big bills are paid for consultants as well?


TO MANY

Posted on 12-08-2012 19:14 | By TERMITE

Even on a good day, millions goes west in this department of any Council but espeocally TCC there is a raft of these feasting annually on the rates that we all pay.


ANNUAL FEAST!!!

Posted on 14-08-2012 10:07 | By PLONKER

The consultants feasting never seems to stop, what is actually done for the mega dollars is a huge concern, but no one in TCC seems to even see, know or waht to realise there is a problem here for everyone else.


NO RESULT FOR RATEPAYERS

Posted on 15-08-2012 12:52 | By YOGI

Just the bills sadly, "No say, just pay ..."


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.