Civic centre debate begins

A unique opportunity to influence a direction and style for the heart of Tauranga City over the next hundred years or so begins.

The first phase of public consultation over the civic centre re-development project begins next week.


What do you think the news city hall should look like?

'What we're doing is starting engagement on city centre square idea,” says Mayor Stuart Crosby.

Council staff are seeking public input to the question: what is a civic heart?

It can mean many things tangible and otherwise, some of which are on the council short list and some are not, yet.

The ratepayers own the city block bounded by Durham, Wharf, Willow and Hamilton streets.

Most of the existing council office accommodation space is unusable because of leaks and mould. Previous public reports show repair costs and rebuild costs may be comparable, opening the way to rebuild the entire block.

As well as the council offices, councillors are looking at a new civic centre including a library to share stories and knowledge, a museum to celebrate history, a performing arts centre, a city square, conference centre, hotel and accessibility and car parking.

'We know that cities around the world have vibrant city centres and our elected members have scoped elements that they put in a list of things they think could potentially be part of this project,” says council communication advisor Amanda Weatherly.

'We know that we need a permanent or long term spaces for city council staff and whether those elements are they could investigate or include the library there, the museum, performing arts centre and cultural centre.

'We are in that unique position at the moment where council needs that accommodation, plus we own the largest piece of land. How can we use that to make it more vibrant city centre.”

For Tauranga residents and ratepayers, consultation also opens discussion on the new civic centre's style and appearance.

What style of central city architecture will provide the focus or backdrop to the city's festivals and other celebrations of life over the next century?

Napier's got art deco, thanks to an earthquake. Oamaru's Victorian stone buildings provide a unique backdrop for the local steampunk culture.

Thames, which also has some remaining Victorian buildings but more in the wood framed corrugated iron style, is also home to a photogenic crew of costumed steampunks, exploited so well in Peter James Quinn's photography.

Tauranga could also go steampunk. A suitably Victoriana gold rush style, city hall civic centre design could be done on the cheap. A bit of cement, corrugated iron and wood, blended with the 21st Century solar panels, wind generators and exterior gardens. The theme would have designers working for free, almost.

But Victorian architecture is generally criticised as a pastiche of old styles dressed up in modern materials. Tauranga's first town hall was Edwardian. Built in 1916, just five years after Victoria's death, it inherited many of the Victorian style faults; concrete trying to look like stone, the fake columns and a bit of gingerbread along the roof line.

It is called ‘classic revival' style – a warming over of boring ideas accepted to a committee of councillors.

It had to be pulled down in the 1980s because the salt wasn't properly washed out of the sand used in the cement, and rusted out the steel reinforcing over time. Staff working there had to sweep their desks of bits of crumbling building each day.

It lasted about 70 years.

The replacement civic centre lasted barely twenty years. Styled in late 20th Century commercial bland, those buildings were never style statements and the unresolved internal faults meant mould growth exploited the leaks that were never stopped.

The civic centre discussion process is a unique opportunity for Tauranga to decide a style for its city hall as an identifier for the city, otherwise it may be another hundred years of commercial, lowest common denominator boring.

15 comments

New Years resolution

Posted on 07-01-2016 11:54 | By Crash test dummies

Get straight into the spending, fast track, pre-determined and as usual expensive beyond belief.


here we go again

Posted on 07-01-2016 12:19 | By The author of this comment has been removed.

I understand from a councillor it is going to be demolished and a 1,000 seat uditorium is going to be built there and is signed off


WHY NOT REBUILD CENTRAL at BAYPARK ??

Posted on 07-01-2016 12:36 | By Watcher 1

With the new Polytechnic, the new Trustpower Buildings Ratepayers will NOT find parking easily so, why not rebuild in the centre of TCC Boundary??. Council has land around BayPark, there is plenty of unused DAY parking also at Bay Park and its much more central, easy to get into and out of as well and Council could sell their current site and buildings which would reduce debt. Do the sums Councillors, you may end up finding that the total proceeds from your existing mouldy building will allow you to rebuild at debt free new building at BayPark? Why Council did not utilize their existing Mount lands which was VERY central instead of selling to Zespri leads to even more questions??


Go Classic.

Posted on 07-01-2016 13:01 | By morepork

Steampunk is a fashion which will fade, Victorian and Edwardian are old hat; why not design it using simple elegance with current materials and modern building techniques? In the next century it will then reflect the current period and, if the design is good, it will be timeless. The theme should be "looking to the future". BUT, whatever is chosen let's make sure it is implemented PROPERLY. There is no excuse for design and building faults leading to mould and damp, whatever materials are used.


Think Ahead

Posted on 07-01-2016 14:48 | By Ron

Why do people insist in building in 2016 a library based on 19th century Carnegie library ideas? The new Tertiary campus will have a library (which the city and regional councils have contributed to already)-how about paying some of the current running costs of a city library to the university to maintain a public library? Ratepayers will be saved ongoing costs of staff running a second hand bookshop under the guise of the fiction lending department, or a video store in competition with ratepaying businesses. The local history room can become part of a new Museum. Non fiction can be looked after by the university librarians. Childrens books can be added to the university collection as a condition of the city contract. There is $20 million saved immediately.


CENTRE

Posted on 07-01-2016 14:59 | By jeancraven@kinect.co.nz

Plan for the future as the current centre has no architectural theme to work to.


Think again

Posted on 08-01-2016 07:59 | By fletch

How about moving the Council to Trustpower old building. Less parking worries for staff


The Bigger Question

Posted on 08-01-2016 08:02 | By The author of this comment has been removed.

It seems that council has decided to move office. OK. Where are the admin offices to be? Permanently rented as at present? A new complex altogether? Where? When? That's the real question!


@ jeancraven

Posted on 08-01-2016 10:13 | By Crash test dummies

Perhaps you should reconsider that thought, the last attempt by TCC to think about this resulted in less than 20 years life span, in fact the Nippon-clippon level added has only lasted about 12 years. Architectural themes only result in cost blow outs and a failure to achieve a reasonable life span.


@ Ron

Posted on 08-01-2016 10:15 | By Crash test dummies

Now isn't that the truth of it. Such waste and repeat wasters ... the answers are so simple.


@ fletch

Posted on 08-01-2016 10:16 | By Crash test dummies

Yes, that is the best idea yet, then sell off the CBD site to be developed by real developers. With their own money and TCC just stay right out of it.


All comments here

Posted on 09-01-2016 11:06 | By Crash test dummies

You are all missing the most important point to be made, that this Council should not be allowed to nsed money.


Other thing

Posted on 10-01-2016 19:44 | By Crash test dummies

TBOP decided to shut the existing office and rent it out, so perhaps they should just have to wait until it is vacant and move back into that space, nothing was wrong with it before now or in the future. let that be a lesson that you don't "walk away" from what you have and then expect the ratepayer to just let you have a replacement glass box replica to get all warm and comfy in just because you "want" it.


Spend other people's money.

Posted on 16-01-2016 15:35 | By PaulM

Why does the admin centre have to be in Central Tauranga? Why not in the Lakes Industrial where all the staff can have a car park too. There is a good Bus service to there, along with a new BP and Countdown opening.Stupid like the new Poly/Uni - 500 parks needed daily for students plus many of Trustpower 450 staff.No doubt Council number will expand exponentially well over the current 550 plus the many subcontractors and others to follow - lease is the real way - ratepayers do not have to own Council property. Typical Grandiose Lifestyle of Local Councils.


@ PaulM

Posted on 18-01-2016 13:30 | By Crash test dummies

Good call on most of that, however numbers are not 550, they are over a 1,000 easily already + consultants. The cost to ratepayers is colossal and counting.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.