Councillor left out in the cold

Western Bay of Plenty Councillor Mike Lally is unhappy with his Mayor’s committee recommendations. Photo: Chris Callinan.

He was the highest-polling candidate for the Te Puke Community Board, but Western Bay of Plenty Councillor Mike Lally has been left completely out of the loop.

Being elected a councillor means he cannot automatically join the board – he must be appointed by the Western Bay of Plenty Mayor. Yet Mayor Garry Webber has declined to do so.

'I am the only councillor who lives within the Te Puke Community Board area,” says Mike.

'The chairman of the board doesn't, and nor do the councillors appointed to the board, [Grant] Dally and [John] Scrimgeour.”

Mike says he has no problem with his fellow councillors, but questions why they were appointed over him, particularly John Scrimgeour, who lives rurally away from Te Puke?

'Why would you appoint a councillor who lives way out in the country, to a board concerned with urban matters?” asks Mike.

For the record, Mike wasn't appointed to any of the boards – although his colleague John also sits on the Maketu board.

'To appoint a councillor who is also chair of a committee to both the Maketu Community Board and the Te Puke Community Board – that tells you something is seriously wrong.”

Two councillors each are appointed to the five community boards in the WBOP, organised geographically. Generally, the appointed councillors represent the ward in which the community board's area falls.

But Mike has been left out of the Te Puke Community Board altogether, while John Scrimgeour sits on two boards, chairs the Long Term Plan and Annual Plan Committee, and is a SmartGrowth appointee, along with the Mayor and Deputy Mayor Mike Williams.

Mike Lally feels he has a lot of support in Te Puke. He ran for the mayoralty against Garry, and although he fell short of winning, he still polled high in his own ward.

'They [Te Puke voters] obviously have faith in me to look after their interests, or else I wouldn't have topped the poll,” says Mike.

Fellow councillor Margaret Murray-Benge agrees it is shabby treatment.

'I was extremely supportive of Garry Webber. I thought he had the potential to be a very good mayor,” says Margaret.

'However, based on the way he [Garry] has organised his committees, I find it despicable. I'm quite angry with him.”

Maragaret has years of experience serving in local government, but never made it past deputy chair in Garry's committee arrangements. As for Mike, she finds it egregious he's been left out of both the community boards and committee chair positions.

'Mike polled well. He got more votes than Garry in the mayoral campaign for Te Puke. Yet he's not included in anything.”

Mike hasn't been able to get a straight answer out of the mayor about the situation. Cynically, he thinks there might be some vindictiveness at play.

'What the mayor is trying to do is disenfranchise me from the voters,” says Mike.

'But that's never going to happen.”

Garry emphasises, however, that this was a council decision, although he plays down the fact they were his personal recommendations.

'There was a proposal for council committee structures and representation. It was a council decision, which was voted 10-two in favour.”

He was unwilling to discuss the motivation behind his recommendations for the Te Puke Community Board.

'I'm not getting into any discussion on individuals. There was a recommendation made, council agreed to it, end of story.”

You may also like....

10 comments

Proof in itself

Posted on 21-11-2016 09:53 | By mutley

A good team player would just sit down shut up and follow his Captain - not go off complaining in public.


council appoinments

Posted on 21-11-2016 11:05 | By phoenix

Hey Mike, The hierarchy in council were never going to appoint someone,prepared to question decision making or stand up for the ratepayers.We have the lowest polling councillor for northern western bay as deputy mayor,and appointed to more committees than you can shake a stick at.The clique at western bay of plenty district council lives on.


Bit of a giveaway...

Posted on 21-11-2016 11:18 | By flashmedallion

Going and having a cry to the newspaper is basically holding up a giant neon sign that says "there's a damn good reason that nobody has any confidence in me". Maybe Mr. Lally should remember back to the messes he kept getting involved in when he was a Councillor in the '90s. Impressed that Margaret Murray-Benge was able to pull her foot out of her mouth for long enough to weigh in on the matter.


@Mutley

Posted on 21-11-2016 12:08 | By Colleen Spiro

If you were in a good team, that might be the case, but when the CAPTAIN effectively closes you down, what does that say about him....so he doesn't even get to represent the people who voted him in.....that is BULL


Check the formline of this outfit

Posted on 21-11-2016 12:22 | By ROCCO

Mike you shouldn't be surprised just look at the connections.The public will work this lot out real quick just keep hammering away and bingo you will have your day in the sun.


Webber as captain?

Posted on 21-11-2016 15:40 | By AndyCap

You would think that the captain of a team would want the best players in his team?


Mike, good luck!

Posted on 21-11-2016 16:23 | By Cydifor

And good on you for pointing out what is happening behind closed doors. Just keep on sticking your neck out and make a difference. You will be the person who stands for real democracy and perhaps that sticks in the craw of those councillors who follow the crowd to the detriment of those you are elected to represent. It is obvious you are well-liked as you polled so well in your own ward - so take heart! I read on Sunlive about the fiasco of 45 minutes-plus of Maori speeches at the swearing-in of the councillors, then hymns in Maori and I believe that some walked out and that the one woman councillor was made to sit at the back. I guess that you were present at that.


@ Cydifor

Posted on 21-11-2016 17:28 | By Colleen Spiro

I was present at the 2013 swearing in and the behaviour of a family member of one of the candidates was appalling, in the way he expressed his dissatisfaction at the Maori part of the proceedings....and it definitely was not 45minutes... some people are just so RUDE, disrespectful and intolerant.


@Cydifor

Posted on 21-11-2016 17:29 | By Colleen Spiro

forgot to say this was TCC I am talking about, and I got it on video


Good on you Mike.

Posted on 23-11-2016 08:19 | By bub.casey@xtra.co.nz

The residents of Sunset Drive in Paengaroa have an issue with the speeding traffic on this 200 metre stretch of road and the lack of school signs on the same. I myself have total faith in Mike Lally as he is the only one who seems to care about what is happening in our township not like others who said they will "sort it out" and we have not seen hide or hair of them. Good on you Mike Lally


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.