Clamour for coastal sirens

Bay of Plenty MP Todd Muller believes the tsunami text alert system let people down. File photo.

'Confused and conflicting.”

One Papamoa mum's experience, and it appears a shared one, of the early hours of Monday morning when the 7.5 earthquake wrecked parts of the South Island and rattled the Bay of Plenty.

MP Todd Muller agrees. 'The text alert warning system let the community down. When it really mattered it didn't seem to work to the level people would expect.”

And the MP has joined the clamour for siren notification. 'This needs to be prioritised.” And he intends to ask questions of the Ministry of Civil Defence and Emergency.

'Clearly there is a need for the community to have sirens – and there needs to be sirens as soon as possible. It's time to prioritise this and ensure the investment to make it happen.”

The Papamoa mum and her family slept through the text notifications and only became aware of the tsunami threat when a friend rang in the middle of the night to warn them. 'I thought, ‘Is this for real?' I went onto Stuff.co.nz and saw there'd been a huge earthquake – and I thought, ‘Yeah, I am going'.”

So she loaded her six-year-old in the car and headed off to the safety of her mum's house in Tauranga. But not her husband.

'He decided he would wait for the siren which is what we thought would happen in Papamoa. So the messages we are getting are messy and conflicting.”

There were a few Facebook posts saying they received the text notifications, but a lot more called for sirens.

'[Sirens are] definitely needed in Bayfair/Papamoa as a large number of people, including us, slept through our texts.”

The Tauranga City Council says its tsunami investment and planning has been in two stages. Since 2013 it's been working on public education, evacuation routes and safe areas people can escape to from a tsunami.

And now that's nearly in place, the council can look towards the next phase of public safety which is how to alert the community.

Todd Muller believes that's something that should be delivered with urgency. 'I totally endorse locals concerns there isn't a siren and the fact there needs to be one as soon as possible.”

There's also political pressure being applied to the council. A notice of motion has been filed with the chief executive demanding it consider tsunami alerting mechanisms for the city. The notice also calls on staff to present an issues and options paper at the next council meeting early next month.

Gary Benner, who featured in The Weekend Sun last week with his Tsunado alert radios, says his devices are sirens. 'But unlike those mounted on poles which are hard to hear, the Tsunado provides the same loud sound in-house.

'They will waken householders and provide a radio and text screen to inform people of the nature of the disaster and what to do. Pole sirens can't do that.”

You may also like....

12 comments

Don't panic

Posted on 20-11-2016 15:53 | By astex

If anyone would care to do a little research via google they will find that in the entire history of Tauranga there has NEVER been a tsunami greater than 1 metre in height. Many areas of NZ have had enormous waves in the past but Tauranga, because of it's position, has NEVER been hit. Perhaps a responsible media would care to check this out instead of spreading fear.


Pretty normal!!!

Posted on 20-11-2016 16:34 | By Jimmy Ehu

response from a bunch of inane bureaucrats!, education and public response??!!!!, well you have just had natures response...., it does not need to be a 3 year decision, your ratepayers demand some action, so just do it!!!!, what would your response have been if lives were lost, from your lack of response, the headline should be...... "Council management show their worth".


Risk management by 20/20 hindsight

Posted on 20-11-2016 16:35 | By mutley

Good on Todd for pushing this issue. But now that he has acknowledged it he is responsible for delivering on it. We have a fine history in NZ of risk management by looking at the past not analysing the future. Why are we now suddenly energised by the risks of earthquakes and tsunamis ? If ever there was a wake up call the Indian Ocean tsunami of December 2004 was surely all that we needed to get prepared. But now, nearly 12 years later, the disaster readiness of Tauranga (especially Papamoa) is woefully inadequate. And, as always, when (not if) the big disaster happens there will be politicians saying how "we must not let this happen to anyone ever again". The power is in your hands now to stop it from happening at all. Proactive risk management not 20/20 hindsight.


The BOP CD email alerts need checking, too

Posted on 20-11-2016 18:07 | By SML

I enrolled on the local CD BOP email alert programme Nov 2011 (I'm disabled), and got the last one during the CD test on Nov 5th 2016. So, where was my alert email on 14th Nov?? When I rang on the Monday, I was told I'd been "de-registered", and the man kindly re-registered me. But I've had NO RESPONSE to how I became deregistered right when I would have expected an alert on 14th!! Surely that when one needs the alert? When there's a CD emergency? I'm still awaiting a response from CD BOP.....


Check your facts iknow

Posted on 21-11-2016 09:11 | By mutley

At the Pickering Lecture run by IPENZ in 2005, it was stated there was geological evidence of a major tsunami found 9km up the Wairoa River. To have left geological evidence the wave must have been at least as large as the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami. There is also apparently other evidence on Matakana Island of it being flattened some time in the past. The same lecture explained that the seabed contour around Tauranga is quite favourable to tsunami wave formation. Luckily, Kaikoura is one of the least favourable areas. So iknow perhaps you should do some proper research and don't blame the media.


@iknow

Posted on 21-11-2016 09:18 | By Papamoaner

Well, we hope your first experience isn't your last. You appear not to understand the difference between research and anecdote. Lack of prior does not make anything immune.


Not everyone ...

Posted on 21-11-2016 09:42 | By chancer

..has a cell phone or email they check in the middle of the night !! What is wrong with the air raid sirens used in UK during WWII, attached to power poles (energy source readily available) at regular intervals along coastal areas & key inland locations. They were more than effective in a war environment what can be so hard in trying that same scenario here. It's been 5 years since Christchurch, now Kaikoura, and still nothing has been done. Pathetic really.


Truthtalker

Posted on 21-11-2016 12:22 | By Wise Chief

Don't Panic, ...You jest with your response that Tauranga/Mount/Maketu Coastal area has not been hit by a tsunami in the past. Please do provide some form of solid proof which is readily available and contrary to the hard geological evidence at hand all about us, which is backed up by word for word transmission of stories or rather warnings about such wipe-outs which have occurred here in the recent past. The most recent one which did big damage and altered the flow of rivers and streams was about 300 years ago and prior to that one on several occasions down the centuries. Nice place to live but as with any other place on the planet, it too is subject to sudden upheavals.


Do something constructive about it.

Posted on 22-11-2016 19:07 | By The Tomahawk Kid

OOooh! Heres something I can get involved in to make it look like im earning my salary.What a waste of time and effort! The people in most danger cant be bothered actually doing anything to save their own lives (that doesnt involve pleading to the council or government to force everybody else to pay to save their lives) so why bother.Your ratepayers DEMAND you force everyone else to pay, so just do it. People living on the coast have the right to do something about the situation though, but it doesnt mean the right to force others to do something.


@Tomahawk

Posted on 23-11-2016 14:11 | By Papamoaner

Difficult to follow your gobbledegook mate, but it appears you don't want your rates used for sirens. So if a big wildfire is heading up your way towards your high ground hacienda, do we send our publicly funded fire service or not?


Papamoaner

Posted on 04-12-2016 12:22 | By Kenworthlogger

The answer would be yes. Same if a tsunami came to Papamoa we would also send the fire engine. We would not want public money wasted on a forest fire warning siren or tsunami siren. I hope this is simple for you to understand.


@kentworthlogger

Posted on 07-12-2016 18:11 | By Papamoaner

Ah, got it now thanks. Sorry, I didn't realise fire engines are amphibious. My brain was depleted by a past life from once being a dumb truck driver in my early 20's.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.