Managed swan shoot is legal

Re: the letter from Phil McKernon (27 May), swan shoot in the harbour on 22 May. McKernon's letter was abusive and insulting, and like his appearance on the TV1 news item of 23 May, he lies in a deliberate attempt to misinform the public about this event with his anti-hunting propaganda.

The shoot is conducted in accordance with local and regional council bylaws, and is specially permitted and overseen by Fish & Game. DOC are also fully aware of it, with DOC staff sometimes attending.
Humane
The intention is that all birds are to be killed as quickly and humanely as possible, but in accordance with the strict safety and procedural protocols that must be followed. Shot birds are then recovered and returned to a collection point where they are tallied and shared out amongst the participants.
This shoot is an important part of the management of the large gamebirds in the Tauranga Harbour, and it has been a one-day event in the short annual gamebird season for many years. However, only in recent years a small number of vocal, self-styled anti-hunting activists have complained to try to end this annual organised hunt. But despite the fact that the shoot is totally legal, Mr McKernon and his fellow agitators have tried to stop, obstruct, or sabotage the shoot, and last Sunday went so far as getting TV1 news cameras to film the event after trespassing over private land under false pretences – several kilometres from the mainland – and miles from where these activists actually live. (Not anywhere near their own properties as they claimed).
Twisted individual
On the TV News report McKernon appeared to be a bitter & twisted individual who could not tolerate or understand how the participants could enjoy the day out, or the fact that they were happy about harvesting prime game-meat for their families, in much the same way that fishermen enjoy the thrill of landing a huge catch.
In short, there is no problem with the organised swan shoot, the problem is only in Mr McKernon's mind, and his ‘perception' that the shoot is wrong is what needs to change.
I have found that with the most intolerant, hard-line anti-hunting activists you don't have to look far to find they have failings, short-comings or issues of their own, and this often can be a reason why they so vehemently condemn and chastise ‘hunters' as a way of building up their own fragile egos or low self-esteem amongst their contemporaries. By labelling the licensed gamebird hunters as 'the shooting Neanderthals”, McKernon speaks volumes about his character and ignorance. Unlike in his native England, hunting in NZ is not the preserve of the social elite or the landed gentry, but of all persons who are fit to hold a firearms licence. Amongst the hunting fraternity, and those at the shoot, are doctors, lawyers, electricians, mechanics, farmers, surgeons, orchardists, engineers, plumbers, salesmen, etc., Basically, people from all walks of life.
Not all things in life are beautiful, and death is inevitable for all. Hunting may not be everyone's ‘cup of tea', and that's fine – that's their choice. But for many in these tough economic times it is an increasingly popular and traditional method for many to put food on the table for their families.
Hunt saboteurs
Unfortunately now in the UK legitimate organised hunts are routinely interrupted by anarchistic, violent, unruly activists known as ‘hunt saboteurs', who will trespass on private land and physically and verbally assault hunters until police or security intervene. As an immigrant to NZ, is this the sort of thing Mr McKernon has in mind for us next? I fear so.
I fully support and applaud the efforts and work of the volunteers involved in organising and running this special shoot – at their own expense – saving the regional ratepayers from footing the bill for an expensive and wasteful professional culling operation.
Instead of writing in to local authorities to complain about this event, I would encourage others to write in supporting it!
Dean Maisey, Tauranga.

You may also like....

8 comments

OVER THE TOP

Posted on 04-06-2011 09:46 | By Scambuster

Have no idea on the pros and cons of this little tiff are however like most things the truth probably lies somewhere in the middle.One thing I do know is that this rant and rave is around 500 words double what most letter writers are allocated.


NEW RULES !

Posted on 04-06-2011 11:11 | By PLONKER

So that is a long letter, maybe the accounting departmetn is on holiday, "mere morals" only get 200 words or less.


Managed swan hunt

Posted on 04-06-2011 13:48 | By algail

I don't hunt or know anything about hunting or the incident referred to in this years swan kill. However If there was much laughter and jolly good fun while taking part in the cull then perhaps it would be less than palatable to many I should think. The shooters may have been taking the lives of pests but one should respect the life they take and do it quietly calmly, efficiently and respectfully. It is not the swans fault they have become pests they are just filling their place in her nature of things. Alastair Bourne


EXTENTED LETTERS

Posted on 05-06-2011 23:22 | By YOGI BEAR

Well one good reason for it is that the less of them there are then less for the dog to chase ... maybe that is why a long letter was permitted?


WEED EATERS

Posted on 06-06-2011 19:50 | By MISS ADVENTURE

And fish love to eat the crap they make, how wonderful that is recycling according to nature an we are culling it?


TROUGH FEEDERS AND MORONS

Posted on 07-06-2011 04:23 | By PLONKER

Strange happenings at the waters edge, perhaps they should just play the music to JAWS, that should clean out the place for sure.


There is a proper way to do this

Posted on 09-06-2011 09:21 | By Hebegeebies

If black swans are a pest then there needs to be an organised cull by Wildlife officers or DOC not some gungho shoot out by duckshooters and their ilk.Backslapping joviality and whisky flasks have no place in what should be an humane and serious operation


USE A CATLAN GUN

Posted on 10-06-2011 12:42 | By PLONKER

And get them all, speaking of which when was the STAFF AUDIT at TCC going to happen?


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.