The state of the housing crisis

When a pregnant 23-year-old Elaina Short goes for 'a piddle” in the dead of night, she crunches her way across the frost to an outhouse, where windows have blown in, the roof leaks and there are gaping holes in the walls.

'I will not bring my new baby home to this,” she declares. That is non-negotiable.


Elaina Short, with her husband Dave and their three-year-old Alyisha. Photo by Bruce Barnard.

And there's sympathy from hubby Dave. 'It's primitive,” he says of the toilet.

And it's only marginally better in what makes do as a family home.

The Shorts subsist in a rented, 15-foot caravan where a tiny fan heater is fighting and losing the battle against the damp and the chill.

They want a state house. They desperately need a state house. They are the faces of the Tauranga emergency housing crisis.

'We are on the waiting list,” says Elaina. They say they registered with Housing New Zealand four months ago.

'We check each week,” she adds, 'but we've been told it'll be six months to a year.” So the 'unplanned new baby” that is due early next year might have to come home to the cold and damp of the rented caravan after all.

Unemployed Dave's a bit shamefaced and tugs deeply on another ‘rollie'. 'It's bloody stressful not being able to provide for your family,” he admits.

And what about wee ‘Bubba', three-year-old Alyisha who's a ‘dead-ringer' for her Mum? 'It's sad because she hasn't known anything different,” says Dave.

What Alyisha is familiar with are continuous colds. 'She's getting more and more sick,” says her Mum.

Alyisha's also familiar with being cramped in the caravan for days with her parents when it rains. 'She hates it,” adds Elaina. 'There are tantrums and I hate seeing her angry.”

And Alyisha's also familiar with meat and vegetables just once a week. It was baked beans and bread again last night. Dad had noodles. That's standard.

'She's regressed,” says Elaina. 'We almost had her toilet-trained.”

Elaina has her own health issues. She's anaemic. 'But the baby is doing fine,” she adds.

The Short's $80-a-week rented caravan is parked up on $120-a-week Maori land in Bethlehem – it's littered with caravans, piles of junk, broken buildings and broken dreams.

And just to ram home the indignity, on the skyline just over the paddocks is a quite different demographic – the full employment, warm fires, full larders and affluence of the Bethlehem Bible belt.

They are the ‘haves' – but it is quite different for the ‘have nots' like the Shorts. And while she might not have much, Elaine has pride and determination 'I'm not moving again unless it's into a house,” she says.

When SunLive drops by the Short's caravan it's the middle of the day and curtains are drawn – perhaps against the cold, perhaps for privacy.

A ginger moggy is parked on top of the microwave. Tidiness and cleanliness don't seem to be a priority. They have bigger issues.

'We are not sitting on our arses,” reassures Dave.

They applied for five private rentals yesterday, they are on the books of several letting agencies and they have looked through 20 to 25 properties since having their Greerton rental home sold from under them three months ago.

'We just get the old ‘don't call us, we will call you' line,” says Dave. 'We are being ignored.” So they ended up in a caravan.

They just don't percolate to the top of the waiting lists and they don't understand why. 'Probably because we're low-earners,” he admits.

But they do understand why.

There's a history with substance abuse, they dabbled in ‘everything' – him with drugs and her with alcohol – but they insist it's just that, a history.

There's Dave's stint in prison. 'A long time ago,” he says. He's a discharged bankrupt and acknowledges 'there's been some bad financial management”.

And one day their child went missing for a time. It doesn't read well.

But, he wonders, should it preclude his family from having a roof over its head – should it preclude them from the basic comforts like warmth and security?

'Now we are trying to do things the right way, but everything seems to be conspiring against us,” he adds.

The Shorts survive on benefits, which means once they have paid for the caravan and the site – and the last couple of payments on their now unregistered and unwarranted car – they have about $60 a week for food.

'I've been on bended knee and begged like a pauper for food grants,” says Dave. 'We have used up our annual $300 allocation.” And it's only July.

The 48-year-old's work career has been a seasonal one. But he's now doing a forestry course, which he hopes might turn a decent hourly rate by the end of the year.

And his wife, who is 25 years his junior, has just started an introductory course in social work. She'd be coming from first-hand experience.

In the meantime they remain positive. 'God will answer our prayers,” says Elaina. 'After all, he provided this caravan when we needed it.”

Perhaps this family needs more than divine providence right now. Perhaps they need some more earthly assistance.

Because how tragic and pathetic, how desperate do you have to be before you're accepted for a state house? SunLive will explore this story further next week.

You may also like....

15 comments

Outside toilet

Posted on 17-07-2015 13:48 | By YOGI BEAR

get a port-a-loo from WINZ


NZ Taxpayer?

Posted on 17-07-2015 13:55 | By YOGI BEAR

Why is it that everyone else has to fix their problems, how fair is that?


YOGI

Posted on 17-07-2015 16:50 | By R1Squid

I agree. There are also State Housing tenants that have boats and Lexus motorcars parked in their driveways.


Really?...

Posted on 17-07-2015 20:40 | By Vuuren

Why would any property owner take a risk by letting people like this live in their properties?.. telling a sob story to get yet another handout! How are the courses paid for? Studylink and student loans which are funded by the tax-payer?.. Oh and I love the statement in the article "Unemployed Dave's a bit shamefaced and tugs deeply on another


All Of You

Posted on 17-07-2015 20:55 | By Survivor

How about instead of most people commenting negatively about this situation (which is doing absolutely nothing for yourselves and only proves how heartless you are) and start coming together/supporting people like what used to happen back in the day when i was a kid. If someone needed help, it was there. This country/prime minister doesnt have a clue and you all sit in your warm homes & judge. well i have also been in very similar situations to these people, growing up & due to my own mistakes. ITS CALLED LIFE! we all are given different opportunities & we are all different people yet the way things have turned out it seems no one gives a dam about the person living next door, or outside homeless in the cold etc etc. it wuld be a different story if you actually knew these people personally.


Part of the solution is...

Posted on 17-07-2015 20:59 | By penguin

...to give up the "rollies." Amazing how much that will save!


Hmmmm

Posted on 18-07-2015 00:10 | By Ebco

Unemployed Dave's a bit shamefaced and tugs deeply on another


Think accomodation is hard to find now?

Posted on 18-07-2015 08:45 | By astex

Wait until the new uni opens and all the students come to town.


Madness

Posted on 18-07-2015 13:23 | By maildrop

Maybe not such a good idea to have another baby when you cannot provide for it. What the hell, someone else will pick up the tab eh? As Dave says, "it's primitive". You're on the money there Dave. Disgusting.


Bottom line......

Posted on 18-07-2015 13:52 | By sambo's back

its easier to beg, when children are involved.


Every one is in the Same Boat

Posted on 18-07-2015 15:55 | By Gemini15

You are what you are and you live how you want to. People like this are shameful, its them whom got themselves into this predicament no one else and its up to them if they want to change their circumstances if they really want to. All you have to do is get off your backside and do something honest about it. Plenty of jobs out there and listed with WINZ & oh I love how they can afford rollies over providing food or a home for the child,talk about being selfish. We've all been here at some stage but hey all you have to do is get off your backside and do something about it. Be a TRUE PARENT and provide for your child instead of expecting someone else to do it for you.


Hook Up With

Posted on 18-07-2015 18:09 | By Towball

A bloke who looks like your father get pregnant with another kid then ask for help . Well done. Then go public with a feel sorry for us story GET REAL. Life is about choices make some responsible ones .


Who am I to judge????

Posted on 22-07-2015 13:09 | By Jack Attack

The numerous negative comments on here about the plight of this human family are a sad indictment of the 'I'm alright Jack' attitude that now seems to be rampant in NZ. I have never been in the position they find themselves in so I cannot judge them. All I can say is, the answer has to come by way of a government that is prepared to seek and aim for full employment for Kiwi rather than waste $26 million (without consultation)on changing a piece of history.


Humanity and empathy

Posted on 25-07-2015 19:58 | By Oneday

I find some of the comments on here sad and pathetic, and quite frankly shame on you. All I see is a family, that has made some mistakes in the past trying to do their best for their child. Every family and child in New Zealand deserves a warm home and good food, It must really nice for those of you that are perfect and have never done anything wrong in their life(dreamers) When I read this article the first thing I thought is how can I help this family. Not everybody in this world has the same opportunities and skills. we are all in this together and all human so show some compassion!


Oneday

Posted on 31-07-2015 16:22 | By Kenworthlogger

Its not about making errors as we are all human its all about taking responsibility for your actions and it looks like they are not doing anything to help themselves. But i totally agree with Jack Attack. Imagine how many houses 26 million would have built!


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.