The rental home scramble

It was like a Queen Street sale. They counted down, the doors flew open and the stampede began.

But they didn't have fistfuls of disposable dollars and they weren't looking for bargains – these were Tauranga's disadvantaged and vulnerable looking for somewhere to live, looking for somewhere to rent.


Home is where the heart is – homeless man Jay Lucas bunks down in his car for the night. Photo: Tracy Hardy.

It's a sellers' market – in this instance, one three-bedroom home at $320 a week and two dozen anxious people scrambling over and around each other for the chance.

'You wanna live here?”

I'm house-hunting with a hopeful, a less-than-hopeful hopeful. 'Nuh! But needs must.”

It's a modest functional home in the back of beyond, crammed at the top of a long muddy drive and dodgy-looking neighbours on loud motorbikes.

But desperation breeds compromise. And when the agent asks if she's interested, of course she is.

It's depressing and demeaning. 'Now I have to wait while they sift through the ‘interested', while they do credit and Tenancy Tribunal checks,” she says. 'The agent will draw up a short-list and the owner will choose on advice from the agent

'Even if I get on the short list, it'll go to a couple. Why do they think a couple is a better risk? Relationships crumble.”

It's a lottery – and invariably the result is 'not a winning ticket”.

Isn't she anxious? She should be because she's desperate, she's homeless, she has nowhere to live – she's out on the street.

And it's one of those suffocating, dark, manky wintery afternoons that drains the spirit. She rolls her shoulders this time.

I suspect she's immune to disappointment. 'I can't let things get me down otherwise I'd be hopeless. And that's not an option for mother.” She's very in charge of her emotions.

But what makes a stunningly attractive, well presented, smart law student in her mid-40s and her two boys such undesirable tenants.

This email from Sue Warburton at Prime Rentals is a clue.

'Hi – we have turned down your application as your checks don't meet our requirements.”

Then it cuts deeper. 'You would be wasting your time coming to this viewing today. Kindest regards.”

'I have wasted a lot of time,” says the woman. 'Two hours a day on TradeMe researching, and then viewing and applying. It's time expensive.”

All this around being a mother and her studies. The law degree would drag her out of this black hole, so would her business studies. But the marks have suffered.

'I've been looking for three or four months,” she admits. And last weekend she had to vacate her rented home because she ran out of time.

'I've trawled through 130 potential renters. I've inspected more than 30. I'm now viewing at least one a day.”

But that email, why doesn't she 'meet our requirements”?

Well, she maybe law savvy and halfway through a degree but she's not money smart.

She admits to having been touched by the curse of the credit card. 'Hideous thing,” she huffs.

There was also a ‘bung' business but she insists her financial issues are historic and have been sorted. And that hole in the wall of a previous renter?

'My son is autistic – it goes with the territory – but it was fixed and paid for. When do things stop counting against me?”

Unfortunately, you carry your record with you. But it was a small victory in the Tenancy Tribunal that's the bugbear.

She discovered she was renting a 'leaker” and won $600 compensation from a property owner. 'I resolved an issue but was left with an issue.”

The decision in her favour means she is now perceived as litigious or difficult.

Either way, this mother, caring for two young men, is now holed up in a motel as a last resort. 'I got a deal, which is only $25 more a week than a caravan park.” She has three weeks there - three weeks to find a home.

What can she expect to achieve in three weeks that she couldn't achieve in the previous three or four months of searching for a rental home?

'I mean, the hell? – how did it come to this.”

Did we see a crack in the iron lady? There's just a hint of anger, frustration and desperation. But not hopelessness, of course.

This is the cold, naked reality of the rental home market. She can see her way out in the long run but across town, Jay Lucas can't.

Jay's settling in for the night. Settling in, in his car, behind work in Hewletts Road. The Toyota station wagon has become home for this homeless 30-something after a 13-year marriage soured.

Jay plays games on his phone, has a couple of ‘rollies' and there's a blanket in the back seat when ‘home' freezes over. Next to the blanket is a backpack containing the rest of his life. 'If I just had some cash,” he says.

Jay is paying $430 a week in family support. This reliable, willing provider doesn't begrudge that. But it would leave perhaps $200 a week for rent.

'Even if I could find a place I couldn't afford the four weeks' bond, the one week in advance and the one week's letting fee – nearly $2000 plus GST.”

He despairs. He just wants a ‘warm, safe, happy environment' for his four children, who he has each weekend. But he doesn't have any answers.

'I've been looking for the right rental for four weeks but it's just money, money, money – about $300-$400 for somewhere I could have my children. It's impossible for us in the lower bracket.”

He uses a toilet inside work, has a very ‘supportive and understanding' boss and he showers and eats with friends.

Going home to the marriage is not an option. 'Not for either of us – or the kids.”

Okay – he could flat. 'That's a possibility.” But he needs space to have his children and they need him.

So two victims of an over-inflated under-resourced home rental market in Tauranga. The Weekend Sun has been told they aren't the only ones.

And a home can't be a shelter from the storm if you don't have one.

You may also like....

15 comments

Where does the OECD

Posted on 12-06-2015 11:19 | By Towball

Report include these people in it's statistics. See Paula Bennett isn't exactly enforcing her gym membership seems largely comfortable . Sue Warburton is walking a fine line as a comment such as hers can only be viewed as deformation of character and is a legal offence . A discriminatory statement . My three dependents don't cost $430 a week to raise . Not everyone is in a position of dictatorship like Sue . I would like to put this Dad in contact with a chap I know of who wants a flat mate and would be happy to have the kids there on a weekend or potentially the Mum equally . Sun live can contact me and I will assist . $430 a week is nuts for four kids plus a roof that is an average mortgage payment !. Challenge others to do same .


helping

Posted on 12-06-2015 13:52 | By bunchof4

Thanks Towball i have passed on to him, and not that anyone cares we didnt end on a sour note or nothing at all it was a mutual decision and one we are happy with, i dont wish for him to be homeless or any of this, in the end i want him to be able to turn up with a smile knowing he is taking his babys to someplace he is comfortable with, he is worryed with flatting that he will be disturbing the other flat mates when he has our 4 kids....


Homeless shelter??

Posted on 12-06-2015 13:58 | By Angel74

For Jay is a safer, warmer option than his car!!!


Thank you

Posted on 12-06-2015 14:44 | By sojourner

for this article SunLive. It is very much over due. Please do more, until you run out of people who cannot pay the insane immoral rents. You won't run out of copy anytime soon.It's not that the houses are worth it, it's just the demand in the market and heartless greedy landlords.Shame on them.


Thanks to SunLive

Posted on 12-06-2015 15:11 | By morepork

... and Hunter for a very insightful piece of journalism. Heart goes out to all those who have to face winter without a roof over their head and especially where kids are involved. It isn't always the lazy who are needy. Angel74 is right that Jay would be better off at the shelter, but it may not be a choice he wants to make. A decent man in a bad situation doesn't need to have what few options he has, removed. The Lawyer lady has a blemished track record and her question: "When do things stop counting against me?" resonates. We all need another chance because we all get it wrong occasionally. Landlords and agents are "risk averse" and you can't blame them. It is a seller's market so they don't need to take risks. Ironically, reformed "problem tenants" may be the best, because they value having a roof.


Hang in there

Posted on 12-06-2015 16:59 | By gforce

hey lawyer lady, keep your chin up, I too had a bad financial record, as a result of a marriage breakup, but have to say I found a fantastic landlord that was able to see the real me and have been renting one of his houses for 3 years now, and I have never missed a rent payment. People will hopefully judge you for who you are. Good luck


I'm looking for a decent tenant!

Posted on 12-06-2015 18:54 | By foxinsox

I have a rental that I want filled with someone that REALLY wants it and is just willing to commit to a rental agreement and pay the rent each week on time and abide by a few normal rules. It is not too much to ask. If any of these people want to contact me perhaps we can help each other?


Huge Thanks

Posted on 13-06-2015 15:58 | By Towball

To the the people who commented and offered support to these two people . Is a small comfort knowing that there are still a hand full of people who care about others, not just themselves .


Hard rental market

Posted on 13-06-2015 18:33 | By Property Manager

Sad to hear you news but every day many good tenants are missing out. How to get to top of list get a copy of your own credit report get written landlord references personal references. We had a solo mum struggling and suggest doing a family profile with photos including her dog. She came back saying she had got a house in 24 hours after looking at dozens of homes. You can get a home but prepare a profile to convince a landlord . We have received 20-30 page profiles and these go to top of list. All the best and a bit bad luck shouldn't, stop you from getting a home . Sadly many good tenants are missing out


Wisechief

Posted on 14-06-2015 09:32 | By Wise Chief

Successive Brit/NZ Governments both Nats & Lab have done a deceptive number on brainwashed now very fearful once brave Kiwis in conning them with what was and still is overseas UK banking interests in a effort to continue NZ good credit rating secure more offshore loans to supposedly run country to sell off as much of NZ as possible. This they N&L have consistently done for greatly increased in debt.WHY? Still weak kneed spineless Kiwis & now new immigrants stand and watch them do same silly ineffective routine day after day well N&L knowing via already accumulated evidence any policy mandates proposed are doomed to fail. Today we have many thousands homeless and living in depraved conditions in this vast bountiful country where less than 1% has been urbanised for people to live on and yet here we are with this evil foisted upon us by British Peoples.


Not so wise chief

Posted on 15-06-2015 08:18 | By Kenworthlogger

Get a job and stop moaning!


About time something was said!

Posted on 15-06-2015 09:32 | By TNH

Even on a good income with no dependant children I am finding the rental market a struggle. I opted to have a dog for protection but property owners don't even take a minute to read your application! So I recently chose to move onto a rural property that allowed animals, owner refused to do any kind of written agreement, has now changed their minds on things and has me by the balls because it is going to be difficult to find another property. I have looked into the option of buying my own property, but without a second income it's harder than paying rent! I have also been in Mr Lucas' shoes and lived in my car for a time, a tent on my mothers' back lawn and shared a garage with a car for a while. And I've always had a job!


Overit

Posted on 15-06-2015 18:51 | By overit

I feel for Jay, $430 a week in maintenance. I had a friend in the same boat with 3 kids, and after paying maintenancwe had $100 for his own living costs.


Good report.

Posted on 17-06-2015 13:58 | By Baystyle

Campbell Live type reporting and a good wake up call. No one should be sleeping in a car in this abundant land. Kiwis doing it hard when billions are leaving NZ in corporate profits. I wonder if our Saudi sheep live in better conditions than some people here?


Overit

Posted on 18-06-2015 18:46 | By overit

Baystyle read the Political Beat above, Operation Desert Storm. It would appear not!


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.