Saturday, September 11, 2010
No climate change in Tga

A retired climate scientist says his analysis of rainfall and temperature records for the last 100 years shows climate change is not happening in Tauranga.
Dr John Maunder's records of Tauranga rain and temperature on a month by month basis show there is no significant trend in either set of climate data.


John Maunder says there is no evidence to suggest climate change is occurring for Tauranga.

"Although I am sure some people will see or think that they can see changes," says John.
"My main point is that though there are some changes, it goes up and down.
"Overall it's a good 100 year record - as good as you can get.
"From 1910 to 1920 there were some quite warm periods in there, but to take it from there to now and say there's been cooling would be wrong.
"There have been some warming periods and there have been some cooling periods."
The temperatures are average afternoon temperatures, but not night time temperatures.
"There really have been no significant changes that I think you should get concerned about," says John.
"People might get upset about similar changes if they live in the Maldives, but in Singapore or Helsinki they would get by without any problems, end of story."
Any long term climate trends are more likely to be signalled by farmers, says John.
"If farmers in the Bay of Plenty begin growing bananas instead of kiwifruit, or the Southland farmers switch from dairy to grapevines - the farming community is pretty astute."
John, who lives in Matua, is former President of the Commission for Climatology of the World Meteorological Organization from 1989 to 1997.
For the last 55 years he's been involved in the 'weather business' in various countries, including New Zealand, Australia, Canada, US, Ireland, Switzerland, and the UK.
His publications include four books: 'The Value of the Weather' (1970), 'The Uncertainty Business - Risks and Opportunities in Weather and Climate' (1986), 'The Human Impact of Climate Uncertainty - Weather Information, Economic Planning, and Business Management' (1989), and the 'Dictionary of Global Climate Change' (1994). The information is prepared so as to provide a 'need to know' background on climate change, and 'global warming' with the aim to promote a better understanding of this complex matter.  

The Maximum Temperatures for each day have been recorded at various sites in Tauranga since February 1913.
From February 1913 to February 1989 the observation site was 'Tauranga Aero', from January 1970 to January 1994 the observation site was 'Tauranga', and from June 1990 to the present day the observation site was the Tauranga Airport automatic weather station.
The data from all three sites is combined into one homogeneous temperature series using the current observation site as the base station. Although adjusting temperature observations from one site to another is not without its difficulties, it is considered that the homogeneous temperature series described in this web page is a fairly true record of what the temperature would have been if the current observation site had been used since 1913, with the understanding that although standard accepted methodologies are used, any adjustments are only estimates of what would have occurred if the location of the temperature records had always  been in the same place with the same surroundings, the same instruments, and the same recording screen.
 
The composite average maximum temperature data from February 1913 to June 2010 for Tauranga shows the following (last updated June 2010):

  Highest Lowest 2008 2009 2010
JANUARY 28.4 degrees in 1935 22.6 in 1997 25.1 25.5 24.0
FEBRUARY 26.9 degrees in 1928 22.2 in 1934 24.0 25.2 24.9
MARCH 24.8 degrees in 1916 20.6 in 1960 23.0 22.7 24.1
APRIL 22.5 degrees in 1938 18.2 in 1992 20.3 20.1 21.0
MAY 19.6 degrees in 1916 14.8 in 1977 16.8 16.2 18.0
JUNE 16.6 degrees in 1916 12.9 in 1972 15.2 14.1 15.5
JULY 15.8 degrees in 1916 12.5 in 1939 14.5 14.5  
AUGUST 16.2 degrees in 1915 11.6 in 1913 14.8 16.2  
SEPTEMBER 18.4 degrees in 1915 14.8 in 1964 17.3 17.5  
OCTOBER 20.3 degrees in 1915 16.0 in 1964 18.4 17.7  
NOVEMBER 22.6 degrees in 1954 18.7 in 1995 20.5 21.3  
DECEMBER 25.2 degrees in 1940 20.1 in 2004 23.3 23.2  

For the year as a whole the highest average daily maximum temperature of 20.3 degrees was in 1916, and the next highest 'warmest years' are 1915 (20.1 degrees), 1928 (20.0 degrees), and 1998 (20.0 degrees).
The lowest average daily maximum temperature was 18.1 degrees was in 1992, and the next 'coldest years' 1923 (18.6 degrees), 1977 (18.6 degrees), 1918 (18.7 degrees), 1980 (18.7 degrees), 1993 (18.7 degrees), and 2004 (18.7 degrees).
The average daily maximum temperatures for each year since the last 'very warm' year in 1998 (which itself was the fourth warmest year on record are: 1998 20.0, 1999 19.7, 2000 19.5, 2001 19.3, 2002 19.3, 2003 19.2, 2004 18.7, 2005 19.6, 2006 19.3, 2007 19.3, 2008 19.4, and 2009 19.5 degrees.

Rainfall
From January 1898 to December 1904, the observation site was the Tauranga Harbour, from November 1904 to April 1907 the site was 'Tauranga', from January 1910 to December 1923 the sites was Waikareao in Otumoetai, from January 1924 to September 1940 the site was at 148 Waihi Road in Judea, from October 1940 to January 1941 the site was at Te Puna, and from February 1941 to the present, the site is the Tauranga Airport.
 
C.S Thompson of the former New Zealand Meteorological Service computed a homogeneous rainfall series for Tauranga and some other stations in New Zealand, appropriate to the recording sites, and the methodology use is published in the NZ Meteorological Service Miscellaneous Publication No 180 in 1984.
 
Although adjusting rainfall observations from one site to another is not without its difficulties, it is considered that the homogeneous rainfall series described in this web page is a fairly true record of what the rainfall would have been if the current observation site had been used since 1898, with the understanding that although standard accepted methodologies are used, any adjustments are only estimates of what would have occurred If the location of the rainfall records had always  been in the same place with the same surroundings, and the recording gauge.
 
(Last updated July 2010)
Tauranga:
The 10 wettest YEARS on record are:

1962   156 % of the long term average
1916   147 %
1917   143 %
1938   138 %
1920   136 %
1956   135 %
1971   133 %
1979   131 %
2005   128 %
1935   127 %
(In chronological order these wettest years occurred in 1916,1917,1920,1935,1938, 1956,1962,1971,1979, 2005, and 1935)

The 10 driest years on record are:
2002   57 % of the long term average
1915   59 %
1982   64 %
1993   66 %
1906   72 %  
1919   73 %
1997   74 %
1973   75 %
1986   75 %  
1999   76 %
(In chronological order these driest years occurred in 1906, 1915, 1919, 1973, 1982, 1986, 1993, 1997, 1999, and 2002)

The 10 wettest months on record:
634 mm in May 2005 (511% of long term average for May)
504 mm in March 1979 (462% of long term average for March)
447 mm in December 1962 (447% of long term average for December)
383 mm in April 1911 ( 319% of long term average for April)
381 mm in June 1925 (293% of long-term average for June)
357 mm in October 1916 319% of long term average for October)
348 mm in July 1951 ( 270% of long term average for July)
343 mm in Feb 1936 (376% of long-term average for February)
331 mm in April 1948 (276% of long-term average for April)
319 mm in March 1972 (290% of lon-term average in March)
(In chronological order these wettest months occurred in 1911, 1916, 1925, 1936, 1948, 1951, 1962, 1972, 1979, and 2005)
 
The 10 driest months on record:
1 mm in January 1928
2 mm in July 1902
4 mm in December 1930
5 mm in March 1943
7 mm in February 1973
7 mm in October 1984
8 mm in January 1900
8 mm in February 1973
10 mm in April 1958
11 mm in February 2010
(In chronological order these driest months occurred in 1900, 1902, 1909, 1928, 1930, 1943, 1958, 1973, 1984, and 2010.)

Official archivist of New Zealand's climate records is the National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research NIWA.
Niwa's 147-year-old national mean temperature series, the 'NIWA Seven-station Series' or NSS shows New Zealand experienced a twentieth-century warming trend of 0.92°C.
This is challenged by climate scientists who say the raw data correctly shows New Zealand average temperatures remained steady at 12.6°C +/- 0.5°C for a century and a half.


Only registered users can post comments. LOG IN to post a comment.
  

Comment by The Master - added on 05 Aug 2010 11:56PM
ISLANDS SUMBERGED
Temperatures and rainfall are but part of the story, it is completely simplistic to think that Tauranga signals the world right !

Get real, add the following sample to the equations: -
1 Atolls and the like are being abandoned because of the increasing salt water level encroaching on fresh water therefore plants and trees are dying etc

2 Ice that is on the land is melting, it runs into the sea, the sea level rises, consequence is as per two above.

3 We know CO2 emissions e.g. ex cars etc has a green house affect, computer models predict this and have been found well short / under estimate the true affect of global warming.

4 To hell with man made global warming, if indeed the earth is warming be it by human or natural means then we are all in trouble here and anywhere.

I rest my case!!!!!!!!!!!
Comment by Rob - added on 26 Jul 2010 12:32PM
Surprise surprise
Obviously it comes as no surprise to myself that these results simply demonstrate what sensible commentators have been saying for a very long time. Despite the high qualifications of many of the AGW commentators in the Tauranga area - Take note that the facts do not support your misguided bleatings! -Rob Smith - Matua

What will be the Rugby World Cup's biggest impact on NZ?

A tonne of tourists will fall in love with NZ.
It will provide the economic stimulus NZ needs.
NZ's roads will be bruised with shattered beer bottles.
NZ rugby playing numbers will increase.
International media exposure will forever boost tourism.
NZ will not recoup the costs of hosting the event.
It's all a load of hype and it won't make a difference.
© Copyright 2009 Sun Media Limited. All Rights Reserved